Thursday, January 19, 2023

God or Not Nothing

Certain of the Sadducees asked Jesus who would be the husband in the hereafter of a much-married woman.  After describing the afterlife of humanity as being in some ways like the existence of the angels (an assertion that is left tauntingly undeveloped by Jesus, though it precludes marriage), Jesus says that “as touching the resurrection of the dead, have ye not read that which was spoken unto you by God, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?  God is not the God of the dead, but of the living.”

Christianity has delighted in holding up Jesus’ statements here as though they were the irrefutable utterances of a philosopher unequalled in all of history.  Indeed, Jesus is the greatest philosopher in all of history, but it was not his practice to utter irrefutable things.  Jesus’ assertions about the character of God, both in this instance and in others, are not presented as though they were logical postulates such as would be liable to testing, because his assertions about the incomparable qualities of God exist by definition independently of any basis for comparison.

God is, and beside him there is no other.  The “no other” part of the assertion might be taken in its immediate sense as “no other god,” but that semblance of “logic” (to stretch the term) which would disallow any other god in comparison to God must also, if taken to its logical conclusion, result in the realization that if God exists, then nothing else as a comparable entity can exist.  Furthermore, it is inescapable that analysis of the character of God is a fool’s errand.  God’s existence does not place him logically in possession of qualities (such as a loving nature) that can be understood as the quintessence of those qualities.  God does not love perfectly while yet other creatures love imperfectly.  We are drawn (we hope) to God because we feel he loves perfectly while other creatures do not, but that is simply our human nature seeking to embrace a character of God in terms compatible with our understanding of “nature.”  Ultimately (though sterilely) we must reckon that God creates the very love that he displays perfectly.  God is, and so there is love.

When our foundational postulate is “God is,” then at least we can strain toward the clarity increasingly attainable as we return again and again to that postulate.  This is in contradistinction to the unfortunate parody of piety that characterizes much of religion.  For much of religion, the foundational postulate is not “God is,” but rather “The universe has God in it and above it,” or “My life has God in it and above it.”  Placing God thus in a context inevitably leads to his diminishment.

An example of this is seen in the Ryrie Study Bible’s comment on the episode described above.  In response to the passage declaring “God is not the God of the dead, but of the living,” the Study Bible says, “For believers there is life after death, a truth rooted in the character of God.”  Any reasonably earnest student of Christianity and its history of doctrines will be able to sense the ridiculously manipulatable elements of the cobbled-together phrase “For believers there is life after death.”  Is this life “for believers,” while yet unbelievers will exist in sentient form forever, or does “for believers” mean that only “believers” will interpret Jesus’ use of the phrase in a certain way?  How many doctrinally-differing definitions are there of “life,” of “death,” or of “life after death”?

Moreover, what could possibly possess someone to write of “life after death” (or indeed of anything else) as being “rooted in the character of God”?  The God of Jesus is the origin and author of anything that might be called “character” (or, perhaps more revealingly, “characteristics”.)  The slightest inclination to view God as the origin and author of everything will reveal that time means no more to God than he would choose it to mean.  The self-same logic that says that God is the God of the living will dictate that God was the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob before ever they were conceived.  This does not mean that our assessment of the “character of God” is such as would allow our conclusion that he is the sort of supernatural entity who would keep his creatures (or certain of his creatures) “alive” in some sense, for some purposes to suit him.  Rather, our prudent disinclination to opine on the “character of God” will present us with a simple yet baffling postulate: neither time nor anything else need mean anything to God.  God does not fill time and space.  God is not the lord of time and space.  Both of these statements are “true,” yet in some contexts (such as many ramblings about the Sadducee-episode above) they are entirely inadequate.

God is.  Other things “are,” but those things are not comparable to God in other than an evocative sense—this is the most crucial element of understanding about God.  Time and again Jesus confronts people with insoluble questions about God, and time and again (and still) people try to solve the insoluble.  Indeed there are many questions and many puzzles that we need to try to solve, but the last thing we need to do is entangle ourselves with conjectures about the character of God.  In a certain sense, our lives are an internal struggle in which the battle is between devotion to God, on the one hand, and devotion to things other than God, on the other hand.  Among those things that are not God there are better and worse things, and in our creaturely limitations those non-God things will be the things we can act upon.

Ultimately, however, a wholesome sense of the divine will be a sense of otherness—a sense that purposeful devotion must be devotion to a God who will frustrate all our attempts at understanding.  God is the best of anything we can understand, and yet when considering God we must admit that ultimately we understand nothing.  In a sense this is unsurprising—nothing is anything next to God.  Or anything is nothing.  When we consider anything finite we grant it the effectual title of “not nothing.”  When we consider God all else should become nothing.

This, then, should be the balance in our lives.  Not the fanatic’s notion of “God or nothing.”  What we must do continually is weigh our attentions to “God” or to “not nothing.”  God or not nothing.

Wednesday, January 18, 2023

The Communion That Awaits

One of the most nebulous aspects of the biblical notion of human virtue (or lack thereof) is bound up in the very text itself.  Commentators have tried for centuries to hash out the scriptural assessment of David as being a man after God’s heart—this same David being so ardently after Bathsheba’s charms and Uriah’s life.  And then there is the riotously incongruous contention of Second Peter, that Lot was an upright man, scandalized by his neighbors—whose proximity he chose in the beginning and chose until the final day to abide.  These two notorious examples differ merely in type and degree, of course, from the deceptions and maneuverings of the much-honored Abraham, but they differ crucially from Abraham to the extent that David and Lot were pronounced virtuous, and the commentators have tried to swallow those pronouncements ever since.

Of course, a perpetual Christian industry has been built around the business of proclaiming a person’s moral stature before God as being other than plain to the person’s fellow humans, and I intend here neither to dispute that notion nor to opine on the various theories of forgiveness, atonement, or substitutionary sacrifice presented by the commentators.  What interests me at the moment is the larger question—separated from entanglements with the examples of specific persons—of God’s pronouncements on relative instances of moral stature.  What does God say is “good”?

God calls certain of the elements of Creation good “in the beginning,” and the entirety of Creation he calls very good.  Inasmuch as God knows everything beforehand, it would be as plausible as anything to conjecture that Creation as a whole merited the assessment “very good,” while the implication that it was less than perfect (as anything that was not God) would play out in Creation’s parts themselves being only “good.”  In the beginning (it would seem only prudent to say) Creation was more “very good” than we might ever imagine.  Was Creation initially Heaven, and was Creation (at least potentially) as much Heaven for the First Couple as would be the “paradise” that Jesus promised the Good Thief?  It does not seem that the scriptures (either by themselves or in light of Jesus’ commentary) are concerned with answering that particular question.

Neither does Scripture answer the question of how the perfect God could create something that was less than perfect—or how such a created entity would bear the blame for its inadequacy.  As above, I do not intend to answer those questions.  What I do intend to discuss is the emerging theme in the texts of Creation being initially more “good” than we can imagine, and then displaying symptoms of moral decay.  As I have mentioned often, it seems inescapable that Adam’s discontent with the companionship of God was to some degree a moral failing—whatever its source—and it seems inescapable as well that we (in this mortal realm) are never to know the source of this disconnect.  Neither are we to know the initial blessed state that slipped from us humans.

But we can know that Creation was at first “very good,” and its parts often merited the assessment of “good,” and the part called “Adam” (followed by the part called “Eve”) was somewhat less good in requiring creaturely companionship when God was right there, and then moments (or years or eons) later the parts called “Adam and Eve” committed the acts that are traditionally (and presumptuously) labeled “The Fall.”  And things became still worse after that.

Creation became degraded because of sin, and the natural order was disturbed, and violence and competition set in.  “Man” got worse and worse, and “every imagination of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.”  Of course, this last statement from Genesis is no more to be taken as definitive than God’s initial description of Creation as “very good.”  What exactly do such assessments mean?  If “every imagination of the thoughts” of humanity was “only evil continually,” how then were generations of helpless (and tiresomely demanding) children brought up?  And would not the “evil” of each succeeding generation be—in all fairness—assessed on a sliding scale comparable to the quality of their upbringing?

Jesus, of course, explodes such contemplations.  He tells us that we, though we are evil, know how to give good things to our children.  We are only so bad or so good—at least as we can subject ourselves to our own observation.  What matters, then, is the question of how we can align ourselves properly with moral demands, properly understood.  And, unfortunately, in the vein of the discussion so far, there is the question of what any further degradation of one’s moral state might look like.  We are a rather depressing lot, but in light of the scriptures and of Jesus’ teachings, how might we get even worse?

When it comes to the question of how we might get even worse, there are Jesus’ warnings about how we are going through life.  And then there are Jesus’ warnings about how we must give up our lives.  Our “lives,” it must be presumed, are moral traps: to just go about living is to get—in the final moral analysis—worse and worse.  We are presented, as was Jesus, with the Temptations.  We seek our own sustenance, we seek our own safety, we seek self-actualization.  Or to use the language of the Temptations, we concern ourselves with bread, we concern ourselves with the minor dangers of stones or the fatal dangers of precipices, and we concern ourselves with our places in the world—our possession of “kingdoms” great or small.

Interlaced among Jesus’ contentions that we must give up our lives are his promises that still greater lives are available to us, here and now as well as in eternity.  In this dichotomy can be seen the choice of proceeding downward or upward: we proceed downward as we pursue our own lives (leading us to multiply Adam’s dissatisfactions endlessly), and we proceed upward as we pursue “life,” which now as ever is about the communion with God to which we are ungrateful heirs.

The sorry business of going downward is seen precisely in the frustration of God’s (and Jesus’) intention of communion.  To become nothing is to become everything that might matter, for to become nothing (or the servant of all) is to partake of the life of all.  On the other hand, there is nothing worse than to stand in effectual defiance of God—apart from whom we have no being—by conceiving of oneself as a truly separate entity (even while perhaps denigrating oneself in the most demonstrative terms.)

The sorry business of going downward is seen precisely, for example, in the contrasting examples of Judas and Peter.  It is truly gut-wrenching to consider how centuries of popular imagination have seen Judas’ misdeeds as the most horrific imaginable, while Peter’s are quickly bathed in our soothing assertions that, after all, any of us might have behaved similarly.  Judas was beset with all-too-human greed (though one wonders what he ever found to do with his pilferings, and he might perhaps otherwise have sold his miraculous abilities to the highest bidder), Judas was at least cognizant of the question of how best to use the group’s resources, Judas was beset by the devil in the same milieu in which so many innocents were similarly beset, Judas did what he did while prompted to an extent by Jesus.  Judas felt remorse, Judas returned his evil blood-money, Judas hanged himself.  Judas was a sorry character.

Peter, on the other hand, was presented on a memorable occasion with Jesus predicting his own death as he intended to meld himself to sinful humanity and share the punishment for their sins.  Jesus was going to make himself the servant of all and was going to make his life a thing that mattered only insofar as it was sacrificed to the larger life of all who would choose the true life of the Kingdom.  Peter wanted Jesus to do something else.  In the simplest sense (the sense least risky in terms of our conjectures) Peter wanted to have a life in which Jesus retained his own life.  Jesus’ rebuke to Peter’s objection was to call Peter “Satan.”  Peter, in a manner that makes the sin of grubby Judas seem like child’s play, was staring into the very abyss.  Peter was seeking to frustrate the very logic that has permeated the scriptural account of Creation’s decline, and Peter was seeking to frustrate Jesus’ incomparable logic of salvation from that decline.  Jesus was going to sacrifice himself for the communion forsaken by creaturely beings from “the beginning,” and Peter—Adam-like—was looking for creaturely companionship.

It is then supremely fitting that Peter (with all the rest of The Eleven) betrays Jesus in the Garden as surely as Judas did, for as Jesus said, whoever was not with him was against him.  Of course, we all betray Jesus innumerable times every day.  David and Lot and Abraham betrayed Jesus innumerable times every day.  On the other hand, the greatest thing that Jesus gives us is the realization that infinite opportunities exist for us to reach for the communion that awaits us upon every instance of self-extinction—every instance of giving up our lives for the one life of the Kingdom.

Thursday, January 5, 2023

Truth Needs Tending

In my last post, I described how “we must rely on the old that we know (or think we know) in addition to the new.  Jesus recognizes this when he speaks of the scribe and a store of knowledge new and old.  He also recognizes, however, (in an extension of the ‘wine’ analogy) how people are apt to prefer the old.  We want to be able to rely on what we think we know.”  Our original task in sorting this matter out must be found by us in our notions of the very origins of our existence.

Adam (in a pristine original state that is idiotically considered by many theologians to be “sinlessness”) is placed in the Garden to tend it.  The man has tasks to perform, and it would be cheap convenience on our part for us to imagine that he would not have had to learn things and to remember things, or to imagine that he would not have felt either frustration or temptation to indulge negative thoughts.  Eve, we must remember, shared Adam’s original state, and yet it must be conceded that she thought negative things about God before ever she ate of the tree.  As I (and I’m sure many others before me) have written, if Adam had reached out to intercept Eve’s imprudent grasp, the woman’s state at that moment could not be described honestly as “sinlessness.”

Mankind (if not viewed through an imposed lens of manipulative theology) has always been mankind.  God, when he observes that it is not good for the man to be alone (though provided the opportunity for communion with his Maker), is not recorded as noting that Adam’s character has changed.  The question of Adam’s original moral state (less than perfect though created by a morally perfect God) is no different from—and indistinguishable in insolubility from—the very question of how a God who encompasses all can create something apart from himself.  We are things in ourselves, and we are not God.  That is how it is.

To return, then, to the matter of how “we must rely on the old that we know (or think we know) in addition to the new”—is really nothing more than to return to the ancient philosopher’s notion of discovering the basis of our thought-lives.  Christianity, unfortunately, has forfeit the opportunity to find such grounding in the “genesis” of its theology.  The belief system espoused by Jesus, on the other hand, begins with stories.  Jesus emphasizes the lessons of the stories, not their particulars.  A seed, for example, that falls to the ground and dies is a seed that is dead.  The “seed” that Jesus is referencing is a matter for consideration, not an actuality to be analyzed.

There are two important lessons to be gleaned from the grounding of Jesus’ teachings in the ancient stories.  The first is a simple one, yet it frames the second lesson and ought to undergird all of our thoughts.  This is the lesson of Adam at first in the Garden, going about his duties.  Anything he thought he learned he might misremember, and anything he thought he knew he might in fact have fashioned to his tastes, rendering it more or less untruthful.  Adam’s chief task is the task that is ever and always ours: the tending of truth.  Truth needs tending.  “Truth” that is thought by us to be held by us, understood by us, unquestioned by us—such “Truth” is the altar of an idol-god, if not the god itself.

The second lesson that must come from the grounding of Jesus’ teachings in the ancient stories is found, as I mentioned above, in the essential thrust in the stories themselves and how Jesus uses them.  A story tells a lesson—a story is not a compendium of ancillary facts.  Indeed, in the larger sense, truth as we might understand it can consist of no more than lessons that we might misunderstand couched in contexts and complexities that we might also misunderstand.  The paring-back of any lesson to its kernel—and the continual examination of that kernel from every vantage-point available—is always our duty.

The manifestation of the opposite of this duty is found—lamentably—in much of Christian theology.  A powerful imagery—and a powerful warning against our infatuation with the things of this world—is found in the Temptation-accounts’ quoting of the devil declaring that the kingdoms of this world have been given to him.  The imagery and the warning, however, are all that exist in the story, and yet some theologians will use the Temptation-accounts (varying though they be in the manuscripts) as treatises on the stature of the devil.  “The earth is the Lord’s” is an eternal strain in the belief system that Jesus espouses, and he enjoins his followers to glean simple lessons from a Creation that reflects the benevolence of God.  Give a theologian (or worse yet, a theocrat) a chance, however, and that person might use the devil’s self-described mastery of the world as an excuse to demand that every wholesome objection to theological tyranny is a work of the devil.  And all because the devil’s claim to ownership of the kingdoms of the world—a claim directed by the universe’s greatest liar at a physically-depleted Jesus—is not countered (or is ignored) by Jesus in the story?

We are always trying to impose meaning on our lives.  This, at least in part, explains why we will make up stories (not always a bad thing) and why we will impose our own meanings on existing stories (a somewhat more problematic thing.)  Please note that I referred to our trying to “impose” meaning on our lives, not to “find” meaning.  This is one of the most important things that I find myself trying clumsily to impart through “roused, readied, reaped.”  “Roused” in our lives can often be a most disagreeable thing.  What I have considered all along is the disciples being roused by Jesus in the garden.  To be “roused” (though our immediate experience might be something or some things rising in ourselves) is to have a set of conditions imposed from without.

What we tend to do in response to being “roused” is usually described, however, in misleading terms.  We “respond”, and so feel ourselves to be the subjects of imposition.  This, however, is one of the greatest types of self-delusion.  When we respond to a set of stimuli, we are in reality responding to a constructed (however hastily-constructed or poorly-constructed) conception of our making.  We collect stimuli and impose meaning on them.  This type of scenario is merely a miniature of our overall response (I use “response” somewhat ironically) to existence itself.  Existence is imposed on us, and we impose ourselves on existence.  It is with a correspondingly sardonic approach that we must address our perpetual protestations that we are merely trying to “find meaning” in our lives.  Balderdash.  We are trying to paste meaning on our lives.  We encounter meaning in our lives inadvertently, and usually (think Jesus in the Gospels) when we have placed our lives aside.

The experiential cycles of “roused, readied, reaped”—long or short, overlapping or seemingly all-consuming, beginning in our lives before we are ever aware of them—are misleading even in the use of “experiential” to describe them.  We do not merely “experience” the cycles—we respond to them, and then we experience the responses, which set off new cycles, and so on.  Unsurprisingly, we throw off into every available tangent our own expressions—our own impositions—of meaning.  To be in this tumble of confusion is what it is to be an imperfect being in the state of, well, being.  We would do well to consider what it is to be a sentient being that exists.  Our mere physical state would be no more—and no more dishonorable—than that of a stone.  Our ability to be sense-receptors would not equate to us being thinking entities.  It must be—as though a purely clinical analysis could be applied—our ability to extract meaning from stimuli that would establish us as sentient beings.

Yet we will allow that stimuli—the information-sources that frame a scenario for our consideration—must be less than (or other than) the scenario itself, and so are limited.  Similarly, our ability to extract meaning is limited.  If we are not God, it would seem inescapable that any experience of sentience available to us is bound to the phenomenon of seizing on a conception of imperfect warrant and overlooking that imperfection.  Our thoughts are the cousins of lies, and the truth itself is a more distant relation—if indeed any of our thoughts are of—shall we say—uncontested parentage.

These musings are not particularly profound, yet if our thought-lives are similarly un-profound, then we should expect that elevated teachings directed at us must be teachings that we address (if in good conscience) in the most basic and unassuming vein.  A snake spoke to Eve in the Garden.  Snakes don’t speak.  The account doesn’t say that the snake is the devil.  What the snake in the account does say is the sort of thing that Eve—indeed any of us—might say to ourselves.  Indeed, what the snake in the account does say is the sort of thing that any of us might entertain and then—in the ancient human fashion—feign (and ultimately delude ourselves) to be the mere imposition of reality.  If the snake didn’t say what was said to Eve, then something else would.

What matters is that Eve ate of the tree, that she stood there moments before intending evilly to eat from the tree, that she stood there moments before that wickedly defaming God in her conversation with the snake, and that in every moment of her existence before that the shared Adam’s desire for creaturely companionship when God was right there all along.  And we are going to devote volumes of theology to a snake?

Moreover, of course, the effectual Christian snake-worship of centering on the narrative of the supposed momentary Fall has allowed for endless churnings-out of snake-oil theologies, while the morally-fatal disease of pretending to be a respondent to, rather than a participant in, the teaching process of Jesus is left unattended.  As I wrote in the previous post, to have “ears to hear” is to always hear anew, a necessary practice that we can attend to only when we understand that “understanding” something can mean only lurching from one partial apprehension to another.

And we must understand that each “understanding” is attended inevitably by some element of imposed meaning attributable to us.  With this we must contend.  I no more than anyone else have a perfect formula for this, but here at least I can present an example.  The snake in the supposed Fall narrative serves as a device.  The “enmity” part that follows has no more immediate substance than a “Just So” story to explain humanity’s discomfort with snakes.  In the tower of Babel story, by contrast, there is an explicit reference to humanity wishing to make a name for themselves and not be scattered over the earth.  To whom is this name to be broadcast—or at least is such a name to be specific to a centered locality on earth?  The only truly sentient beings on Earth in the biblical conception were humans—supernatural beings would not be tied to a terrestrial realm, and the greatest way for humanity to create a name for themselves would be for humanity to fill the earth with accomplishments.

It seems that the “name” part of the tower of Babel story—not merely furthering the narrative—is a description of humanity’s perennial imposition of meaning on surrounding circumstances.  As is ever our tendency, the people after the Flood say the Earth—containing only themselves and the rescued species on its surface—was populated by innumerable sentient other-beings.  Such is how we impose meaning on our existence, now as ever.  Such is what happens when we forget that truth needs tending, and instead we let degraded truth, and partial truths, lead to untruths.

Thursday, December 22, 2022

Always Fleeting and Always New

Change in plans.  I just have some notes I want to make, although I should probably console myself with the notion that notes, not treatises, are really what a blog is about.

“Roused, Readied, Reaped” has as its architecture a familiar notion of a cycle or arc of life, but insofar as the “roused, readied, reaped” phenomenon happens in the lives of creatures, unfamiliarity (or confrontation with the “alien”) is an intrinsic element.  Experientially, change is alien, growth is alien, learning is alien.  And of course, as I have written before, the divine is in the first instance to be viewed as alien to us, with every substantive instance of affinity between us and the divine to be seen as miraculous.

This can provide insight into what Jesus must mean by “seeing.”  In a set of unsettling (and theologically unsettled) statements Jesus tells us to pluck out our eyes if they cause us to sin.  The jarring quality of the statement (independent of the fact that it is meant to be jarring) is presented to us chiefly by our limitations of analysis of the teachings of Jesus.  We are drawn almost irresistibly to fancied commonalities with Jesus, and we have the corresponding aversion to the alien.

It is, however, to the alien we must look if we are to find truth.  It is also to the alien we must look if we are to avoid sin.  God’s purity is alien to us.  The sin that separates us from God is, however, most mundane and familiar.  We would do well to note that Jesus is not warning us from sinful members of our bodies.  When Jesus tells us what to do when our eye causes us to sin, his statement is predicated on the notion that we have had experience of what happens to us when we cast our eyes in a certain direction.  Similarly, we have experience of what happens to us when we put our hands to this or that, or when we direct our feet here or there.

The remedy of having one’s eye cause one to sin is to look elsewhere—anywhere, if necessary.  The remedy is to look to the alien, and any search for God’s truth will lead of necessity to the alien.  It is the age-old phenomenon of “the dog returning to its vomit” that characterizes sinfulness.  Indeed, anything that has become familiar to us is apt to be a danger.  When Jesus speaks of new wine in new wineskins, he is speaking of our need to not only learn new things, but also to be willing to let learning change our very selves.  It is for this reason that the notion of time-honored “Christian growth,” lurching up already in the epistles, has little or no basis is the Gospels.  Jesus does not direct his teaching to the building up of knowledge, but rather to the breaking down of internal barriers, each breach of which makes a person to some extent a different person.

Of course, we are apt to resist such change—such yielding to the alien—and we are aided in this resistance by the fact that we must rely on the old that we know (or think we know) in addition to the new.  Jesus recognizes this when he speaks of the scribe and a store of knowledge new and old.  He also recognizes, however, (in an extension of the “wine” analogy) how people are apt to prefer the old.  We want to be able to rely on what we think we know.

Reckoning, however, that we must be willing to give up all to follow Jesus, we must admit that it is incumbent upon us to be open to new things, and to be open to new views of old things.  This is what Jesus means when he says things like, “whoever has ears to hear, let him hear.”  We, indeed, hear such things spoken from pulpit and podium, but rarely do we register such things in the immediacy that characterizes Jesus’ teachings.  Let us hear—and believe we understand and accept—a teaching of Jesus, and for the rest of our lives we will hear such a teaching repeated and accompanied by “whoever has ears to hear, let him hear.”  To us, however, that usually seems like an admonition for us to recall our experience of learning the thing in question.  This is a horror.  Nothing learned from God is ever really understood by us—that is the essential nature of an equation that includes the perfect and the imperfect.  If truth is directed to us by God, it must be renewed continually by us in our reception.  “In our reception” is the key—knowledge of the things of God is never to be recalled in terms of a previously-accepted teaching and reinforced by a conscious desire to strengthen a belief already held.  Truth from God is to heard anew in every instance—and hopefully in as many challenging, alien instances as possible—from the very first reverberation of sound and from the very first glimpse.

Connection with the Great Other is always fleeting and always new.

Wednesday, December 14, 2022

Dismal Proceedings and Dismal Results

One of the most depressing aspects of trying to engage in criticism of Christian theology is having to address actual contentions of Christians who are trying to explain the Jesus of the Gospels.  The Jesus of Christianity is another matter, of course—the Jesus of the rest of the New Testament, the Jesus of Christian tradition and of the practice of claiming that among dozens of faith traditions yours has the “simple truth”—this Jesus can be explained.  The Jesus of Christianity can be explained because the denominations have decided who and what Jesus is, and invariably they find their variant Savior in the Gospels.

But the Jesus of the actual Gospels cannot be so easily explained—a difficulty that exists, of course, only if one thinks he needs explaining.  And the very business of “explaining” is problematic in itself.  Explaining invariably involves drawing out an image of the entity in question from agreed-upon pre-existing notions.  “This” is explained in terms of “that.”  Unfortunately, our thought processes then consign that which is “explained” to the periphery of more mundane understandings—the more-or-less known exists at the edges of what is known.  The rub is in whether we can hold to a notion of God (or Jesus) as more-or-less known.  In the Age of Discovery the edges of the map could be left blank, or be thought perhaps the abode of monsters.  The theologians’ tendency to form a picture of Jesus from a store of received theology and then to explain him as he exists in the Gospels results usually in a “Jesus” who is a monster.

Such it is often in theologians’ attempts to explain our current topic: The Lord’s Prayer.  Jesus, in the Prayer, throws us up against a duty to grasp for a different world than that which we prefer to imagine.  In the Prayer we are deprived of that very “knowledge” base—our experience-worlds, individual and communal—from which we might try to launch a voyage of “explanation.”  Accordingly, it is from concept-denying apprehensions of an estimable “Other”—God above all names and all nouns—that we must try to grasp anew the mundane reality of our existence, a reality that in our more self-assured moments we claim we would discard in a moment to be closer to God.  Instead, of course, we attempt typically to try to explain God and the things of God, with predictably dismal results.

In my next post I will present an example of such dismal proceedings.

Sunday, December 11, 2022

A Life is a World

In my last post I wrote:

“ . . . we must reject the notion that God is meant to be understandable to humans if only humans will allow his sovereignty to be appreciated in transcendence across concepts common to our experience.  Concepts are not the way we bridge the chasm between ourselves and God.  Concepts are the way we bridge the gap between our not thinking of God and our thinking of God.

“Concepts are the way we can remind ourselves that God cannot be conceptualized.  God is the Perfect Other, not the Perfect Thing, not the Perfect Things, not the Perfect Infinitude of Things.”

This truth can be found in the Lord’s Prayer, usually related as in Matthew:

“. . . Our Father which art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name.  Thy kingdom come.  Thy will be done in earth, as it is in heaven.  Give us this day our daily bread.  And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors.  And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil:  For thine is the kingdom, and the power, and the glory, for ever.  Amen” (Matthew 6:9-11, KJV).

In light of this blog’s insistence on God being beyond conception (The Great Other), the following can be revealed:

“Our Father which art in heaven, Hallowed be thy name”: Our heavenly father resides in a plane or state or whatever that we cannot conceptualize, and Jesus is dismissive of our attempts to understand any particulars of the heavenly.  Of course there will be provision for us there, but Jesus assumes that we will take that for granted as well, and not dwell on it.  Of course we might hope to reside there, but we will exist “like the angels”—whatever that might mean.  There may even be graded honors associated with the “hereafter,” but Jesus is neither concerned about that nor even—apparently—privy to its particulars.

As far as the word “name”: There is no place here for the sophomoric notion than a literal name means something in itself.  Jesus says in Matthew 18 “For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there I am in the midst of them.”  Many twos or threes or throngs have “gathered together” in the literal name of Jesus and wished or done the greatest of horrors—neither the name of Jesus nor of the Father are expressed in letters or sounds, but in renown associated with reverence.  “Hallowed” in the context of the Lord’s Prayer must refer to conceptualization, not naming, and it is as foolish to imagine that we can conceptualize God as it would be to imagine that we can ever process a “name” sufficient for the divine.  God’s name is hallowed ground—believed to exist, but drawn back from in prudence.

“Thy kingdom come.  Thy will be done in earth, as it is in heaven”:  Once analysis of the prayer is properly begun, the rest follows naturally.  The supplicant is looking to a re-establishment of existence as the realm of God’s incomprehensible sovereignty, such as had at first confronted Adam.  The world of Adam’s conceit—the place of familiarity and identification for which he and all his progeny have yearned—must be supplanted by the alien—the alien, that is, of God’s sovereignty.  Asking God to do godly things in the world of mankind’s conceit is both ridiculous and impious.  We must ask only for a new world such as existed when creation was new.

Indeed, it is inescapable—and intrinsic to the logic of Jesus’ teaching—that to have a “life” is necessarily to have a “world.”  To “lose one’s life” is to allow one’s world to go with it, and for it to be supplanted by the world of God’s design—a world of unfamiliarity being supplanted endlessly by unfamiliarity.  We have no place of residence to which we can properly claim title, and no legitimate notion of inviting others to our place of residence unless they be the unwashed, the unruly, the dangerous—people who cannot repay hospitality and are as like to repay it with hostility.  That’s what Jesus says.  That would be for us a world with which we might never be comfortable.  Small wonder that the denominations preach the tidy householder’s security and spout about such hideous things as a “Christian worldview.”

“Give us this day our daily bread”: Supplication for what we believe we need in the world we believe to exist is rendered in the Prayer with as short shrift as possible.  Indeed, given Jesus’ disdain for bread alone and his insistence that God knows what we need before we do, the business of our asking for what we think we need borders on satire.  Why would we not rather simply ask to never be hungry?  Jesus’ description of what we might do with faith as small as a mustard seed would dwarf the filling of our stomachs.

“And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors”: Once driven through the bottleneck of “daily bread,” the prayer broadens out again to exploration of the unimaginable world for which we must ask.  “Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors?”  To paraphrase the young Hamlet, who then shall escape damnation?  The emphasis of this portion of the prayer—as indeed in any aspect of our attachment to the divine—must be the effectual dis-attachment we feel when faced with the impossibility of satisfying God’s requirements of us.  We might harbor fantasies—fantasies, that is, in terms of our understanding of our Adamic worlds—of being told, “Well done, good and faithful servant,” but Jesus rather places in our mouths, “we are worthless servants.”  If only our actual existences were such as would allow us to grasp for the former praise, when in actuality we deserve only the latter condemnation.

“And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil”: Yet, as regards the above paragraph, need the situation be so dire?  Does not Jesus promise whatever we might ask?  Unfortunately, we cannot ask for some “thing”—that is, some aspect of our existence to be added, or removed, or altered—and expect any real improvement in our state.  As long as our world exists—as long, that is, as our life exists—we will always find advancement in any aspect to curl back upon itself with a vengeance.  Drive out one devil, and seven others will accompany it back.  “And lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil” is asking for a new world—a new universe, a new existence—in which we are neither tempted nor faced with the prospect of testing.  The phrase is asking for the world that Adam rejected—the world that we all might be expect to reject, Adam or no Adam.

“For thine is the kingdom, and the power, and the glory, for ever”: This is the world—the kingdom—to which we must draw ourselves.  This is the world in which all that is estimable is estimable because it is of God, not because we find in ourselves affinity for it.  As I quoted myself above, “God is the Perfect Other, not the Perfect Thing, not the Perfect Things, not the Perfect Infinitude of Things.”  To say, of course, that we can “draw ourselves” toward the kingdom of God is next to meaningless.  Salvation will always be a mystery.  What is important about the Lord’s Prayer as regards salvation is the fact that is supplies a (usually missed) insight into the quandary of salvation.  A person who strives for salvation is really asking to be overtaken by mercy—striving being insufficient.  A person who understands properly the Lord’s Prayer is simply approaching the matter in the larger view.  We cannot ask for salvation as reward for what we do in our lives and in our worlds (which are really the same things).  We can, however, ask to be made offspring of the world of God—that is, to be overtaken by mercy working out across experiences alien and unasked-for, experiences that will drive us away from the familiar and from our tendency to find our gods in what is like us.  Whatever else might be said, the God of the Lord’s Prayer is not like us.

Thursday, December 1, 2022

Confessing the Perfect Other

My exploration of the idea of God as the Perfect Other must start with a confession.  I have had a type of thought—and I will not say the thought itself is a bad thing—which I think is an understandable type of thought.  The thought, which I have entertained on and off for a number of years, is basically a conjecture to the effect that God is meant to be understandable to humans through a challenging of humans’ ability to conjecture beyond “normal” thought.  That is, God is meant to be understandable to humans if only humans will allow his sovereignty to be expressed in transcendence across concepts common to our experience.

The chief example of this type of thought as I have experienced it—and intermittently attempted to embrace it—is in Luke (and in slightly different form elsewhere in the Synoptics.)  In Luke 10, Jesus responds approvingly to the following answer from a “lawyer” about the most important aspects of the law:

“And he answering said, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy strength, and with all thy mind; and thy neighbour as thyself.”

My fascination with this passage arose from a notion that we were being challenged to test our limits of understanding of God by employing a certain logical device.  That is, if our love for God is supposed to be deserving of all of our capacities (heart, soul, strength, mind) and yet we are to love our neighbor, what then can we conclude but that—in some sort of pantheistic fashion—our neighbor, in order to be an object of the love which we must devote in its entirety to God, must be for us a part or aspect of God?

This conjecture, I must be careful to point out, is at least in part independent of the notion that Jesus is to be seen in our fellow humans.  To speak of us viewing other people as Jesus is more an evocative statement than a declarative one.  We can never forget that other people are not in fact Jesus—are not in fact possessed of the qualities of Jesus—and in any event in the lawyer’s response it is not “Jesus” or even “Messiah” that is phrased as the object of a person’s love, but God himself.

The lawyer says, in effect, that we are to give God all our love, and also that we are to love each other.  We do not solve the quandary thus presented by claiming that “in a certain vein” (such as persons potentially being believers being connected to Jesus being connected to God) we are all part of God.  God in such an instance of analysis is not God, but is—in part, at least—reduced to a physical, temporal phenomenon.  How this might be, we can attribute to “mystery,” but it would be just as “logical” to contemplate a “mystery” in which the love we must feel for God is as much different (and mutually exclusive, and independently overlapping) from the love we must feel for each other, as God himself is different from humanity.

God is different from us.  That is why he is worshipped.  God is not worshipped because he is like us, though we might frame our worship in terms of the familiar.  For example, we might declare that God’s love for us is as the love of mother for child.  Of course, to complete the thought, we must say that even if our mother’s love was to fail us, God’s love would not—which is not really a statement of praise to the Almighty.  What we might really mean is that our appreciation of God’s love for us is as our appreciation of the Perfect Mother’s love—which is really to compare God to himself.  And that how it ought to be.

To rephrase my contention from above, we must reject the notion that God is meant to be understandable to humans if only humans will allow his sovereignty to be appreciated in transcendence across concepts common to our experience.  Concepts are not the way we bridge the chasm between ourselves and God.  Concepts are the way we bridge the gap between our not thinking of God and our thinking of God.

Concepts are the way we can remind ourselves that God cannot be conceptualized.  God is the Perfect Other, not the Perfect Thing, not the Perfect Things, not the Perfect Infinitude of Things.

Following the Path of Expiation

It is unfortunately quite telling that much of Christianity cannot state with authority why Abel's sacrifice was looked upon with favor,...