Wednesday, February 8, 2023

Lain Aside Their Conceits

In my last post I wrote:

“Even a notion that we are pitiful parts of nature with pitifully inadequate naturally-derived intellectual capacities is a notion that places its holder metaphorically above, looking down.”

We must reckon always that our limitations are not confined to our inabilities to attain some goal that we visualize, nor even confined to our inabilities to frame our goals with certitude.  Our intellectual limitations extend to our inability to remain ever-mindful (for who could?) of the fact that our merest thoughts are constructions of our own making, constructions that are revealed—in moments of unsparing introspection—to arise in unplumbed recesses of that which we blithely call our “selves.”

I will not feign concern over how the preceding might play out in natural philosophy, but I am concerned about the prospect of how a concerted awareness of our limitations will play out in an attempt to grasp Jesus’ teachings.  In a world festooned with schemes of overarching philosophy, Jesus’ teaching seems to be focused unflinchingly on the momentary and on the experientially immediate.  As I have written before, a logical analysis of Jesus’ teachings and of his references to the Scriptures will lead us to examine carefully the state of humanity from the very beginning.

Is it not the case that humanity, viewed in light of the beginning of Genesis, has always struggled with an inability to grasp the momentary and the experientially immediate?  Adam was presented with such a state—a state that we as humans would prize presumably above all others—in his initial opportunity of fellowship with God.  The man for whom it turned out it was “not good” for him to be alone was of course merely “alone” in terms of his own “kind”—Adam was ever in proximity with the Perfect Other who had created him.

When Adam and Eve ate of the forbidden tree, their response was one of trying to manage time and place and circumstances—to writhe away from “the momentary and the experientially immediate”—and to maneuver thereby toward some perceived better state.  Responses of immediacy (either fleeing directly to God seek forgiveness or waiting submissively for God to deliver judgement) would have been infinitely preferable to hiding, and we are not surprised to find in the teachings of Jesus an emphasis on one or the other preferable approach, or on a combination of both.

The story of humanity from creation on down through Noah is often understood in terms of declining morality, and is often taken in gravest terms as a cautionary tale, but two major elements of conventional analysis are inherently problematic.  One element—which plays havoc with the operation of an “origin story”—is the tendency to imagine that logical analysis of the stories can be based on an understanding of “human nature.”  One example of this is found in attempts to criticize Adam on how or whether he—in the run-up to “The Fall”—exercised properly his role as family head.  A simple reading of Genesis without such predisposition will reveal that the male role of family head was in that very process being formulated (which throws a sour note over the conventional notion that the traditional family is “God’s design.”)  What we call “human nature” was forged in an interplay between God and his creation.

The second problematic element of the conventional analysis is to describe the decline of human morality as being reflected in a more and more bestial (with apologies to the animals) state of the human heart—as though “right thinking” could serve as something of a remedy.  Here the notion of humans understanding their predicament (we don’t) begins to assert its fatal influence.  Our hearts are to blame for making us have horrid thoughts in our heads, but if we will truly use our heads we will understand that—as was evident all the way back in darkened Eden—it is visceral yearning for reunion with God or addled submission to the approach of God’s righteous judgment (or a combination of the two) that can lead to salvation.  Theories of salvation (and the attendant and even more horrid prospect of human theories about God’s nature) cannot lead to salvation.

How then does evil proceed through the beginning of Genesis?  Already, before the Flood, it is said that every imagination of the thoughts of humanity was evil, but (as I have written before) that evocative statement would scarcely account for the manifest ability of humans to still raise children and to still maintain a civil society.  Jesus describes a quite normal, though admittedly coarse, society carrying on unawares before the Flood.

God’s choice of Noah as an exemplary person would seem to be in tune with an attempt to refine fallen humanity, though it might scarcely be thought that God had forgotten that he might save Noah alone and make for him a wife out of a rib.  Instead God dilutes Noah’s essential nature (if indeed humanity is becoming generationally debased) by making his genetic influence a minor fraction of that of post-Flood humanity.  And it is no secret what then happened to Noah’s family.

Clearly, the notion that people in themselves are simply “getting worse” does not stand as a description of the sorry state of civilization depicted in Adam (and Cain the murderer) and Noah and the Tower of Babel.  There are, however, whispers and utterances and shouts in the Genesis account of the true, developing, and insidious element that proceeds to dominate “human nature.”  Humans are beginning to conceptualize, and visualize, and theorize about their state.  The immediacy of moral empathy (the sense that we live in a universe of right and wrong) is being supplanted by the distanced conjecture that we apply to moral philosophy (a universe of thoughts about right and wrong hoisted up Babel-like on other, more-or-less substantial, ostensibly-foundational thoughts about right and wrong.)

In short, the stage is being set for such scenarios as flush-faced upright citizens squirming about in a crowd, hoisting stones around a quavering adulteress (curiously unaccompanied by an adulterer), and then a more sober citizen catches the attention of one of them and asks, “Seriously?”  (Or some such scenario.)  Or, “Are you really going to leave that poor sheep in the gutter?  Seriously?”

As I wrote in a previous post:

“Adam and Eve were not thrown into a world of despair because they were given the ability to know what was right and what was wrong.  They were thrown into a world of despair because they were thrust into the realm of the challenge that Jesus has for us—our eyes were opened, the eyes of our race were opened, to know good and evil, not to know WHAT is good or WHAT is evil.”

And as I wrote just above, there are whispers and utterances and shouts in the Genesis account of the true, developing, and insidious element that proceeds to dominate “human nature.”  Humans are beginning to conceptualize, and visualize, and theorize about their state.  That “state” includes necessarily anything people can think about, and that includes God.

Human beings went from a state of offered communion with God (Adam’s initial state), to a state of natural communion with God (Adam offered God’s garden and God’s creatures), to a state of human companionship in communion with God (Adam and Eve before the “Fall”.)  Clearly, “falling” was going on all along, and at every stage humanity demanded the actualization of their growing conceptualization-system.  The episode with the forbidden fruit was a dismal and unsurprising development, and it stands out most starkly in the explicit references to humanity aiming to understand their condition—an understanding to which, in the final analysis, only God can lay claim.

Men began to call upon the name of the Lord.  There was a time when the “name” of the Lord would have been inseparable from an unspoken renown of a practical inability to exist from moment to moment (as fair a guess as might be made of the newly-created Adam’s state) without God.  To “name” the humanly un-nameable, to speak of the Great “I Am,” is never doable for a mortal without a tinge of presumption.  To say that men began to call upon the name of the Lord is potentially to describe a moral slippage, not a healthy development, and it is of a piece with the general trend of people to concoct a conceptualization-system.

Humans began to create frameworks of thought that consisted of the things of the imagining, not of the things of God.  If there was but an iota of justice in the notion that Cain deserved to be avenged seven times (though we really ought to leave Cain’s “deserving” this or that between him and God), then Lamech in the reasoning of mortals might claim a more manly and courageous stance in declaring that he would exact revenge of seventy-seven.  There is something in what Lamech says, but to object that this “something” might not stand the scrutiny of God’s perfect judgment is no more than it would be to say that all human moral postulations are to some degree suspect.

And at last, the evil humanity before the Flood is supplanted by the evil humanity after the Flood.  Of course, it might always be said that the blanket condemnation of every inclination of the pre-Flood generations was unique (though uniquely unimaginable), although one wonders if such a condemnation of a people was merely supplanted in the popular imagination by more lurid references to this or that people being as bad (or worse) than post-Flood Sodom and Gomorrah.

It would seem, however, that the most revealing insight about Noah and his dysfunctional family is in just such a notion as “a condemnation of a people.”  The pre-Flood generations were bad enough, and violence seems to have filled the days in which—as Jesus reminds us—they carried on much as people in a “civil” state ever have.  There does not seem, however, to have been a system of conceptualized violence against people unborn or unconceived.  Noah’s generation took care of that.  Noah awoke from his stupor and condemned the progeny of Canaan to (presumably) unending and abject slavery.

Cain killed a relative he was unhappy with (though Abel could scarcely have been thought to have wronged his brother.)  Noah refrained from violence against Ham, though Ham had—in Noah’s conceptualization-system—wronged his father Noah.  In the immediacy, Cain (with malice aforethought) plotted his innocent brother’s death.  It would be difficult to contend that “evil” as overtaking people’s hearts was in greater measure reflected elsewhere than in Cain’s case—yet is it really the case that the sad Genesis narrative is describing the dismal progression of urges worsening, rather than something else worsening?

In fact, what is worsening in Genesis is not evil in itself, but rather the enshrinement of evil in human conceits.  Jesus can call people “evil” without batting an eye, and he can expect people—at least people of wholesome orientation—to accept the characterization as “evil” in stride, while working to understand some greater point.  (We, being evil, know how to give good things to our children.)  The enshrinement of evil in human conceits, however, is what is really reflected in the tragedy of Genesis.

Noah would have done a thing of (comparative) mercy to have struck Ham down on the spot.  Instead, Noah condemns Canaan (good luck with that, theologians) and his progeny to innumerable generations and innumerable tortures and innumerable murders (as befitting “the lowest of slaves.”)

This is what really separates us from the will of God, at least in the teachings of Jesus: the perpetual tendency toward rationalizations, a tendency that—in moral scenarios as elsewhere—leads us to ignore our own beams and emphasize others’ motes.  We are always looking to frame our existences, when in reality our existences are framed for us, in manners that we will never understand and that will always seem alien to us.  We can read Scriptures that tell us that we can never see God, and in a moment’s time we will opine on the nature of God.  What is that, but looking at a caricature of God?  In the realm of our experiences, what is that but presuming to see God?

And when we are not presuming to look at God, we are presuming upon the character of God’s universe.  Such conceptualizations are not evil in themselves, but they lay out before us and before each other table upon table of intellectual weapons and poisons.  What, in the midst of these horrid tensions, does Jesus require of us?  Are we not to be rewarded, are we not to find understanding of the means to salvation, in our attempts to understand our situation?

We are not.  In our attempts to understand our situation, we are no different from Adam clutching fig leaves to himself.  Fig leaves have their purposes, and clothing has its purposes, and seeking and asking and knocking have their purposes, but they do not have the purposes we imagine when we are trying to do the will of God.  The only ultimate purpose of all of our strivings is to remind us of the bittersweet futility of our striving—we ask, seek, and knock so that we will know that we already possess that for which we ask, seek, and knock.  We grasp for the kingdom so that we will know we already possess it.

And when we are seized by the futility of our strivings, we are cast—fortunate beings!—into that scene in the dim Garden, offered the chance to run in search of forgiveness or to quiver mutely in anticipation of judgment.  And when we are seized by immediacies of moral import—twice fortunate beings!—we can respond as God would have us, resolving ourselves to the endless, enveloping Otherness of God’s perfection as we see all experiential existence in a cup of water handed to the thirsty.

This, at least, has resolved for me part of the puzzle of Jesus describing at the Judgment how the saved helped him without knowing they were helping him—when Jesus in the gospel testimony had given away the ending of the story.  The saved who helped Jesus without knowing they were helping Jesus were the persons who had lain aside their conceits in the moment, in the immediacy.

Thursday, February 2, 2023

Two Ways to Be Wrong

In my last post I wrote:

“The only commonality we might have with God is a sense of good rather than evil, and that sense is the only abiding torment that we face.  This is the architecture of the life that we must find in the kingdom of which Jesus speaks.”

And:

“In the world of Jesus, in the kingdom of God, right and wrong, good and evil, are all that exist.  Nothing changes but the notion of what we see with our eyes and hear with our ears.”

In the world that intrudes constantly upon us—the world to which we succumb too often, the world that distracts us—there are many challenges (and many of those challenges are constructed in the form of things that we need ostensibly to do in order to make our lives fulfilling.)  We will make many mistakes and missteps in addressing those challenges, and (it is to be hoped) we will maintain a healthy awareness that such things will happen.  As regards the kingdom of heaven, however, it is often the case that we will be thrown into panic or near-panic at the thought that we don’t know what we are doing.  Making mistakes about what God requires of us is what religion is supposed to allow us to avoid.

However, the notion that we must hear perfectly with our ears and see perfectly with our eyes is as ludicrous as the notion (as I have written before) that we can hear some truth once and enshrine it (or, rather, our conceit that we have understood it) once and for all.  We need to learn things over and over again, and we need to make mistakes over and over again.  Hearing and seeing are living things, and fallible things.

As I wrote in my last post:

“Adam and Eve were not thrown into a world of despair because they were given the ability to know what was right and what was wrong.  They were thrown into a world of despair because they were thrust into the realm of the challenge that Jesus has for us—our eyes were opened, the eyes of our race were opened, to know good and evil, not to know WHAT is good or WHAT is evil.”

We would do well to consider afresh constantly the predicament of Adam and Eve.  (This would stand opposed to the endless re-hashings of the “Fall” stories that are really told backwards—Adam and Eve did this or that because some fifth- or sixteenth- or twentieth-century notion of the “salvation economy” requires such a basis.)  At present, I would say that the growing sense of apprehension that would appear to afflict the first couple is really no different from that which afflicts us as we try to comprehend Jesus’ admonishments about the kingdom of heaven.  As I wrote last time:

“Our lives are good and evil, permeating everything about us and everything around us.  Our worlds are good and evil, permeating everything about us and everything around us.  We are angels and devils moment by moment.”

If we are really the duty-fettered progeny of Adam and Eve, we would not be surprised if the most basic admonishments related to us by Jesus would be well-understood to apply to the first man and woman.  Consider the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew, and consider how it would apply most pointedly to humans—then as now and as ever—trying to wend their ways through the trials of life.

“Blessed are the poor in spirit: for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.”  Being “poor,” it must be admitted, is no virtue in itself, but here Jesus is apparently describing detachment, and in view of his other teachings, it would be expected that “poverty” really equates to unconcern about possessions (and a willingness to celebrate others’ enjoyment of what the world has to offer) such that the believer can be held to possess all—in the sense that possession really means anything.  Adam and Eve had nothing at first (and we might in charity attribute to them mixed feelings about the raiment procured for them by the death of animals), and the beginning of possessions for them and their immediate family was followed hard upon by strife over how to sacrifice some of such possessions to God.

“Blessed are the meek: for they shall inherit the earth”—a particularly poignant imagery if (as a timeless maxim) it is seen to apply to Adam and Eve and to all of us as their children.  Being the opposite of meek, of course, has been seen as the usual way to gain and to pass on an inheritance in the earth.  Jesus’ lessons in the Sermon on the Mount are certainly not practical guidelines on how to prosper in this world.

What is generally not noted, however, is the fact that the Sermon on the Mount also does not consist of guidelines appreciable for their particular content.  To be merciful, to be pure of heart, to be peacemakers—these are all descriptions of dispositions, rather than specifics of thought or behavior.  And to “hunger and thirst after righteousness”—that is a wonderful thing, but it still leaves the believer to find out what in particular is righteous.

In addition, it is the case that Jesus’ longer discourse here does not limit itself to descriptions of dispositions that are devoid of particular content.  Jesus actually supplies his listener with a source of content about moral requirements, and it is scarcely what one would at first expect.  The listener’s moral duties, incredibly, extend not only to what he or she might internalize individually, but also to what other people might through their own dispositions impose on the listener:

“Therefore if thou bring thy gift to the altar, and there rememberest that thy brother hath ought against thee; Leave there thy gift before the altar, and go thy way; first be reconciled to thy brother, and then come and offer thy gift.”

And if that is not enough:

“Agree with thine adversary quickly, whiles thou art in the way with him; lest at any time the adversary deliver thee to the judge, and the judge deliver thee to the officer, and thou be cast into prison.”

The simplest way to characterize Jesus’ approach to the moral requirements of his listener is to say that Jesus demands that the listener give himself or herself all the worst of it—not a particularly specific guideline, but at least a guideline that tends toward a starting point in meekness.  Perhaps the most helpful thing that this guideline provides is a bit of insight into the intractable nature of moral decision-making.  Such decision-making is so difficult that is usually as prudent as anything to grant one’s opponent’s position.

So we are really all just floundering around.  And we are supposed to be such wonderful things, made in the image of God.  If we are mindful of the “floundering around” part, however, we can begin to understand the best ways to conceptualize our place in God’s universe.  We are of course, flawed—but then all of Creation must be considered as “flawed”—since the only thing that is not flawed is God (even if the only flaw is not being God.)

And yet we are creations of God, presumably created exactly (that is, without flaw) as God intended.  Here it is really the case that our ability to understand is being exceeded.  We cannot imagine that God can do anything imperfectly.  Can we at least imagine that God went perfectly about conceiving of an imperfect Creation, and then went perfectly about creating it?

The key here is “conception,” as we might understand it—a thought process.  Of course, we can say that anything that God thinks of as existing can therefore exist—although that really exceeds our own thought processes.  One problem, however, with our thought processes is that—however we might claim to appreciate their limitations—we are led continually to ignore those limitations.  One source of this difficulty is the fact that—virtually by definition—thought processes are imagined to be separate from the rest of Creation, and in a position to opine about it.  Even a notion that we are pitiful parts of nature with pitifully inadequate naturally-derived intellectual capacities is a notion that places its holder metaphorically above, looking down.

But if all is connected (whether by participation in a divine Creation or a natural universe) then all thought participates in that connection.  In the realm of Jesus’ lordship, of course, the divine aspect would be that which controls—Creation is God’s, and by God’s volition—and humanity’s place and character both had God as their Designer.  Even the “man in the image of God” idea is entwined in our understanding with our lack of understanding, being an idea that is both more esoteric than we can comprehend, and also an idea complicated with the linguists’ warning that “in the image of God” as we say it might mean either “resembling God” or “as conceptualized by God.”

What I propose here is that, within the scope of Jesus’ teaching, the concept of “thought” does not possess the neatly-sequestered character we moderns assign to it.  Jesus, for example, does not merely utter a curse against an unproductive fig tree—he tells the tree that it is cursed.  In Mark, Jesus follows that up by telling his disciples that they might speak to mountains, and be obeyed.  Thought—as an intrinsic element of Creation—exists always and everywhere: here or there, more or less emanating from God or his creatures, more or less understood by us, more or less capturing our attention.

When the notion of thought is not parceled out in our conceits, not assigned by us here or there or granted by us as an aspect only of certain creatures, then “thought” and its attendant phenomena can be viewed in a manner more consistent with Jesus’ teachings.  If “thought” exists in gradations, then it can be understood as existing in more or less distilled forms.  In our modern Western conception, for example, there are such things as topics, and questions, and answers.

In a conceptualized Creation mediated by God, however, any situation impinging on an element of Creation is effectively a topic, any experience is a question, and any decision is an answer.  A stone consisting of a locus of chemicals proportionally distinct from its surroundings is approached by a lava flow, the stone becomes heated, the stone fractures.  Ridiculous it would be to describe that as the stone’s topic, question, and answer—or even to describe that as the stone’s situation, experience, and decision.

But what of a plant placed in unusual circumstances, subjected to stresses, and then—predictably, as a botanist might assess—flowering or not flowering?  Are those stages at least a situation, an experience, and a decision?  What of a female animal in heat, approached by an interested male, and submitting (or not) to his advances?  What of a chimpanzee presented with a puzzle, permitted to explore it, and then taking some course to solve it?  Are we not seeing the melding of situation into topic, of experience into question, and of decision into answer?

If the processes of thought are understood as potentially permeating Creation—the Creation formed at God’s thought—then the elevated notions we have of “thought” as a rarefied quality of humanity must come into question.  And so also must we question the even more rarefied status we accord to logical thought.  We all as humans live through situations, experiences, and decisions—and those things run riot in our internal lives, much though we might like to pretend they do not.

These contentions, then, can place us in a better position to view the competing variants of Jesus’ ministry.  At times—to the crowd—Jesus spoke in parables.  At other times he spoke to his disciples plainly.  The standard notion in Christianity has been that the disciples got the better, the more authoritative, and the more substantial teaching—though, to be fair, one must reckon that they got to hear the parables as well.  And we must also reckon with the fact, as I have said, that the Gospel of John has Jesus start and end his ministry despairing of his disciples’ understanding of the proper source of their belief.

Parables or explicit theology—they are simply two ways to be wrong.  Or to be right, though it is usually more prudent to assume that we are wrong.  Only on this basis, meek though it might be muddled, can we begin to construct a foundation for understanding Jesus’ teaching.  As I quoted myself above:

“The only commonality we might have with God is a sense of good rather than evil, and that sense is the only abiding torment that we face.  This is the architecture of the life that we must find in the kingdom of which Jesus speaks.”

Thursday, January 26, 2023

To Cast Ourselves

I ended my last post with:

“What is really happening overall—if we are courageous enough to accept it, if we are courageous enough to conceptualize human ‘belief’ in a manner such as Jesus attributes to us—is a continual recapitulation of the belief-experience.  We reach out to the unknown.  We draw back.  We reach out to the alien.  We draw back.

“We have belief-experiences that we undergo through suffering and perhaps sacrifice, and we never want to face again the prospect of the journey to those belief-experiences.  And then we have to take again the journey to those belief-experiences.  That is what belief is, if we are ever to know it in truth.”

That is what belief is—the last thing (as I suspect for most of us) that we want belief to be.  Of course, the aspiring believer will usually declare his or her willingness to suffer anything in exchange for the possession of a satisfying belief scheme.  And then (as I would hope for all of us) we discover that one of the least likely things to experience in a valid belief system is satisfaction.

On the other hand, a person who claims to possess a satisfying belief system is a person for whom the sting of all questions has been soothed.  I say “sting,” since there is nothing about a satisfying belief system that requires all questions to be answered—the believer has merely to be assured that God (or whatever conceptualization of divinity) will take care of everything of substance.  For the believer, questions are either answered or rendered innocuous.

The conceptual realm—however “awe-inspiring” or “mysterious” or even “scary”—that the believer inhabits is really the world of the believer.  As a parallel example, the most determined materialist can maintain that the universe is purely physical (while yet, of course, entertaining the notion of “ideas” and such as subjective manifestations of that physicality), but in the experiences of living, “the world” of the materialist exists as a set of ideas.  The concept of the world-globe is real to the materialist, as is the experience of occupying an infinitesimal portion of its surface, but “the world” as a whole cannot be encompassed by the materialist’s vision nor spanned by his or her grasp.  “The world” of human experience is an idea.

Similarly, the believer in a religion exists in a world of concepts.  For the believer, it may be God and not some notion of curling space-time (or some such) that exists as the periphery of everything that can be conceptualized, but the upshot is the same.  A satisfying belief system is a “world.”  I say this as something extremely important, because—as I have written before—the totality of one’s experiences in a world is really nothing more than a life.  We are “roused, readied, reaped.”  We are born to a set of experiences that surround us—and their impenetrability is coterminous in our experience with any notions we might have of “infinity” or of “the extent of the universe”—the verbalized meta-horizon of our world.

So much for “roused.”  To be “readied” is to affect, and to be affected by, our circumstances (though, sad to say, there is no guarantee that we are being “readied” in what we might term proper fashion.)  And then we are “reaped”—tossed into some hereafter realm not merely as ourselves but as ourselves refined or degraded by our experiences here.  It is small wonder that we might want all of this to “make sense”—and indeed it is no great sin to want all of this to “make sense”—but this is all of a piece: our life in our world.

Jesus will deny us our lives.  Jesus will deny us our worlds.  “Life” is dying to what the world knows as life.  And the world that we know is to be supplanted by the Kingdom of God.

But how?  The question remains, “How?”

We exist, and we are surrounded by what we think of as “not us.”  That which—in our estimation—constitutes our “selves” is defined by us in contradistinction to whatever is not our “selves.”  We are alive in the world, and we are not the world.

It has been the common human approach to religion, as far as being alive in the world is concerned, to consider that we must do good things, and not do evil things.  The history of Christian doctrine, however (“Christian” being inclusively defined) has ranged from blunt assertions that “good” people go to Heaven, all the way to assertions that no observable (nor indeed internally ratified) “good” aspects need be seen in an Elect to whom are attributed the boundless goodness of the Savior.

And so, despite the vast differences in theology, the denominations share what I described just above.  To repeat myself, we exist, and we are surrounded by what we think of as “not us.”  That which—in our estimation—constitutes our “selves” is defined by us in contradistinction to whatever is not our “selves.”  We are alive in the world, and we are not the world.

But Jesus says we are to give up our lives for the kingdom of God.  Jesus says we are not to live in “this world,” but in the kingdom of God.  How then can we attempt to follow the dictates of Jesus without merely going about throwing up quotation marks all over the place?  For that is really all that theologians do—saying that we need to give up “our lives” for “life in Christ,” that we need to forsake “the world” for “the kingdom of God.”  Actually, that is not all that theologians do.  Having started off with quotation marks, they graduate to capital letters, and we must read of Truth and Freedom, or worse yet, of Real Truth and Real Freedom.

Yet still the question remains.  In the conceptual framework of the challenges leveled at us by Jesus, what are we to make of the persistent question of how to act in the context of what we find facing us?  We are roused to our individual existences, and we must face the passing of time, and we must face the passing of ourselves from the realm that we detect around us.  How can Jesus be presenting a graspable challenge, when he tells us to give up our worldly lives for lives in another world?

I contend that Jesus makes no demands of us that are not implicit yet inescapable “in the beginning” to which he refers repeatedly.  A persistent thread in Jesus’ teaching is for us to be responsible for telling right from wrong, while yet he assumes that our lives will be governed largely by religious dictates that we could scarcely begin in our individual lives to sort out, or to examine in minute detail, or to discard as necessary.

He asks which of us will not lift an animal out of a pit on the Sabbath.  He is not telling us to decide that all religious rules are wrong.  He is not telling us to be Jews, or not to be Jews.  He is telling us that our lives in the world are analyzable in terms that defy the boundaries of our existences.  Our existences, as our inclinations will naturally direct us, are understood by us as the placing of our attentions to what is right and what is wrong.  In the world of Jesus, in the kingdom of God, right and wrong, good and evil, are all that exist.  Nothing changes but the notion of what we see with our eyes and hear with our ears.

Adam and Eve were not thrown into a world of despair because they were given the ability to know what was right and what was wrong.  They were thrown into a world of despair because they were thrust into the realm of the challenge that Jesus has for us—our eyes were opened, the eyes of our race were opened, to know good and evil, not to know WHAT is good or WHAT is evil.

Our lives are good and evil, permeating everything about us and everything around us.  Our worlds are good and evil, permeating everything about us and everything around us.  We are angels and devils moment by moment.  When Jesus called Peter “Satan,” it was because no more powerful word was available, not because he was “trying to make a point.”  When Jesus told a crowd that they were children of the devil, he would have known full well, if he was “trying to make a point,” that some people might have misunderstood or some might have only half-heard him.  In our usual mind-set, we would be troubled that some people might mistakenly really assume that they had truly been equated with the devil.  Yet what ought that to be to us?  A thousand times a day we deserve to be called “the Devil,” and we know it.

A thousand times a day we face the quandary I opened with:

“We have belief-experiences that we undergo through suffering and perhaps sacrifice, and we never want to face again the prospect of the journey to those belief-experiences.  And then we have to take again the journey to those belief-experiences.  That is what belief is, if we are ever to know it in truth.”

To be born again, to be born from above, is to throw ourselves at what is good.  None of this has to do with any life-experiences necessarily translatable into things done by us as individuals in the world—as though we as individuals mattered, or as though the world mattered.  When Jesus glorified God, Jesus was throwing himself at what is good.  When Jesus cried out, “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?”, Jesus was throwing himself at what is good.

Our duty is to cast ourselves at the Perfect Other who is the Perfect God.  The only commonality we might have with God is a sense of good rather than evil, and that sense is the only abiding torment that we face.  This is the architecture of the life that we must find in the kingdom of which Jesus speaks.  How this will happen for us is unsurprising.  As I quoted myself above:

“We reach out to the unknown.  We draw back.  We reach out to the alien.  We draw back.”

Monday, January 23, 2023

To Know It in Truth

I ended my last post with:

“The Good Thief throws himself across the void of his suffering and into the arms of One whose character is utterly alien to himself.  I think there is much to be found in examination of our duty to embrace likewise a reality in Jesus that is utterly alien to the reality we possess.”

The Good Thief is caught up in an episode of unimaginable torment—torment heightened perhaps by elements of his story that might make the characterization “Good Thief” seem as quaint as it is.  Whatever evil deeds he committed, they seem to him such as might be satisfied only by the loss of his life—perhaps the loss of his soul.

The Good Thief has all of his prospects—dismal though they be—before him.  He chooses in his agony to ratify a conceptualization of innocent suffering—and of unimaginably gracious forbearance of human frailty—presented to him by his witnessing of Jesus’ crucifixion.  The Good Thief imagines that he and his fellow criminal are similar in their misdeeds and their just punishments, yet the Good Thief reaches out to that which is alien to him.

We do not know what happened to the Good Thief—or to his spiritual life—in the ensuing few hours of his earthly existence.  Perhaps it is even the case (for who would wish it differently?) that he and his criminal fellow were insensate by the time their legs were broken.  What we do know is that—as we humans experience that which captures our attention—crucifixion is the last thing that happened to the Good Thief.

The Good Thief was not cast to the ground and released fortuitously from his bonds by the earthquake, nor was he allowed to escape with his life in the confusion that would follow.  He was not given a chance to feel his momentary connection to Jesus fade.  He was not given a chance to face again hunger or fear or any of the other travails that would hound him as an escaped criminal.  He was not given a chance to assume his old life, and he was not given a chance to wonder if his feverish petition to the doomed preacher was merely a blurring recollection.

The Good Thief, hanging in his last moments on a cross, was dealt as final a fate as that which seized Judas, swinging from the tree.  Yet just as the finality of Judas in the context of his treachery is to be contrasted to the drawn-out out agonies of Peter (and his equally undistinguished ten comrades) in the aftermath of their flight, so also the experience of the Good Thief is to be contrasted to that which might happen to any of us, seized as we might be in some mood with fervent conviction and then, in some ensuing frame of mind, overcome with doubts—doubts perhaps of even the most fundamental aspects of the “faith” that we had at once believed we possessed.

I say this not as mere conjecture.  Jesus dealt at length with the disciples on precisely this score.  The chief repository of this teaching is the Gospel of John—the gospel that includes almost at its very beginning Jesus needling Nathanael about his sophomoric notions of what might cause a person to hail Jesus as “the Son of God,” “the King of Israel”:

“Because I said unto thee, I saw thee under the fig tree, believest thou?  Thou shalt see greater things than these” (1:50).  Jesus is going to deal with his disciples about belief, and there are going to be hard lessons.

Indeed, it can be scarcely sufficient to say that Jesus teaches the disciples—and us—hard lessons about belief.  Were it not for our persistent ability to succumb to distractions or to let our memories fade—which ought to give us pause about whether we are serious enough about our eternal fates—we would really have cause to claim that Jesus administers to us not lessons, but tortures.  All one need do is gather—even for the heightened concentration of a few moments—the various parts of the ending of John, in order to perceive the architecture of that torment.

The first interaction that Jesus has with a disciple at the start of what is conventionally called The Farewell Discourses is an interaction with Peter:

“Simon Peter said unto him, Lord, whither goest thou?  Jesus answered him, Whither I go, thou canst not follow me now; but thou shalt follow me afterwards.  Peter said unto him, Lord, why cannot I follow thee now?  I will lay down my life for thy sake.  Jesus answered him, Wilt thou lay down thy life for my sake?  Verily, verily, I say unto thee, The cock shall not crow, till thou has denied me thrice.”

And the Gospel of John ends with Peter in the agony of being asked—thrice—by Jesus if he loves Jesus.  Between the bookends of these two episodes is the text of Jesus’ most explicit teachings about belief.  The teachings are timeless, but their delivery in the text is punctuated by momentary and electric interactions between Jesus and the disciples:

“Let not your heart be troubled: ye believe in God, believe also in me.  In my Father’s house are many mansions: if it were not so, I would have told you . . .”

So the predispositions of the disciples, not just their experiences of Jesus’ ministry, can be understood as part of the understandings between the disciples and Jesus.

“And whither I go ye know, and the way ye know.  Thomas saith unto him, Lord, we know not whither thou goest; and how can we know the way?”

And:

“If ye had known me, ye should have known my Father also: and from henceforth ye know him, and have seen him.  Philip saith unto him, Lord, shew us the Father, and it sufficeth us.”

And so Jesus is telling the disciples what they know, and yet they know not that they know it. 

A short while later Jesus says:

“Believe me that I am in the Father, and the Father in me: or else believe me for the very works sake.”

And so Jesus is telling the disciples that they need to believe that he is to be identified with the Father—but, failing that, they can at least believe that he speaks with divine truth because he does things that human beings ought not—in human estimation—to be able to do.

It is no great stretch to contend that the disciples, for all the benefit they have had of three years of Jesus’ ministry, are little better off than the Good Thief.  They are presented with the opportunity to follow a leader who is too good to be true, and they must decide if they will venture into an alien experience-realm in which that which is too good to be true can yet be true.

No one can really do what Jesus is asking, and Jesus knows that no one can really do what he is asking.  This is revealed when he says to the disciples:

“These things have I spoken unto you in proverbs: but the time cometh, when I shall no more speak unto you in proverbs, but I shall shew you plainly of the Father.”

For his pains, Jesus has the disciples say to him a few moments later:

“Lo, now speakest thou plainly, and speakest no proverb.  Now are we sure that thou knowest all things, and needest not that any man should ask thee: by this we believe that thou camest forth from God.”

And in reply, almost as though nothing of substance had been imparted since Jesus’ exchange with the credulous Nathanael:

“Jesus answered them, Do ye now believe?  Behold, the hour cometh, yea, is now come, that ye shall be scattered, every man to his own, and shall leave me alone: and yet I am not alone, because the Father is with me.  These things I have spoken unto you, that in me ye might have peace.  In the world ye shall have tribulation, but be of good cheer; I have overcome the world.”

The believer in Jesus will believe, and then will not believe.  And then it will all happen again.  The believer in Jesus will believe in an explicit theology of Jesus, and then will believe in an untethered theology that flails and grasps at what seems like truth.  It is not strange that such things happen.  Indeed, they will happen.  Jesus knows they will happen.

What is really happening overall—if we are courageous enough to accept it, if we are courageous enough to conceptualize human “belief” in a manner such as Jesus attributes to us—is a continual recapitulation of the belief-experience.  We reach out to the unknown.  We draw back.  We reach out to the alien.  We draw back.

We have belief-experiences that we undergo through suffering and perhaps sacrifice, and we never want to face again the prospect of the journey to those belief-experiences.  And then we have to take again the journey to those belief-experiences.  That is what belief is, if we are ever to know it in truth.

A Reality in Jesus

In my last post I wrote of Jesus’ commands to his followers as being impractical (to put it mildly) means of establishing “affinity with all Creation that makes sense only in light of a call to reach out to an awesome dis-affinity—communion with God, the Perfect Other.”  The world—Creation--is the thing with which we may interact (or at least it is in the world where we might strive to interact with the divine), yet of course we are at all times expected to reach out for the otherworldly.

Unfortunately, we tend often to morph our responsibility to reach out for the otherworldly into a fancied responsibility to reach out for an “another-worldly.”  That is, we assign God to an abode that we visualize as some sort of parallel universe to our own.  Such illegitimate (or at least imprudent) assignment of God to “his heaven” merely degrades our appreciation of him, and I mean this to apply even to protestations that “of course God is everywhere” or “no dimensions can contain God.”  The mere statement of God as being unbounded can reflect either a valid attempt to yield to his ineffable nature, or it can reflect something unseemly like God visualized as a sort of all-seeing time-traveler.

Ultimately, despite our most earnest attempts at piety reflected in characterizing God in poetic or evocative terms, we are in fact deprived (and quite rightly) of any substance to our conceptualizations of God.  God is not the best of this or that, nor the highest of this or that.  Granted, there is nothing wrong in the immediate sense of our musings about God as the best and the highest, but almost immediately all such musings will shudder apart.  God is the author of qualities, not merely the paradigm of (positive) qualities.

What then is the conceptually-translatable version of God (or at least the best available of such versions of God) to which we can pin our attempts at communion with him?  As ever, I will defer to the utterances of Jesus.  When Jesus refers to the Comforter, he refers simultaneously to “the Spirit of truth.”  Of course, when we think of the divine, we are quite correct to think of such things as love, charity, mercy, forgiveness, and if we reckon—again, quite correctly—that we can never really comprehend God, we must admit that his love, his charity, his mercy, his forgiveness, and everything else we can attribute to God are worthy subjects for our contemplation, yet those are qualities that are understood by us in terms of God’s relationships with his creatures.  God’s truth, on the other hand, pre-exists any manifestation and stands—again, at least as far as we can imagine—as co-equivalent to God himself.

I do not claim to be able to assert simplistically that God is truth.  I cannot, however, ignore Jesus’ characterization of the Comforter in John as “the Spirit of truth,” and I cannot depart from the age-old association of the Comforter with the Spirit of God and therefore with God himself.  The persons of God will always be a mystery to mortals.  Additionally, the quality of “truth” is especially acute as an understood aspect of the divine alone.  We mortals can love too much, can be charitable in excess of prudence, can be merciful even sometimes to the detriment of the recipients of our mercy, can be forgiving too soon, too much, or on too little evidence.  All these things we can do, but we can scarcely be too truthful.

Truthfulness seems to be an especial characteristic of God.  Indeed, it is difficult if not impossible for us to see how we could progress from one moment to another without the fanciful versions of our reality that we understand as “reality.”  Everything from our momentary sensations to our most sober philosophies constitute approximations, at best, of truth.  Something entirely truthful (if we are to be “truthful” with ourselves) would be alien to us.  The quintessence of truth would be the full knowledge of God, and as above I will defer to age-old wisdom that says a full knowledge of God would destroy us.  The truth of God is alien to us, despite any conceits we might possess about our desire for truth.  What we must desire, in the end, is communion with the Perfect Other—communion with the One who is as alien to us as he was to Adam.

Jesus’ teachings about the Comforter are contained to a great extent in his discourses in John, and for our purposes here I will present a lengthy quote:

“Nevertheless I tell you the truth; It is expedient for you that I go away: for if I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you; but if I depart, I will send him unto you.  And when he is come, he will reprove the world of sin, and of righteousness, and of judgment; Of sin, because they believe not on me; Of righteousness, because I go to my Father, and ye see me no more; Of judgment, because the prince of this world is judged.  I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them now.  Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.  He shall glorify me: for he shall receive of mine, and shall shew it unto you.  All things that the Father hath are mine: therefore said I, that he shall take of mine, and shall shew it unto you” (John 16:7-15).

What is most important about this passage from John for our purposes is its manifest emphasis on “the Spirit of truth” as more than an honorific.  The divine “Spirit of truth” here described is also presented as truth in its simplest form.  “Sin,” “righteousness,” and “judgment” will be addressed not by the visible imposition of an overt actor, but by truth itself.  “Howbeit when he, the Spirit of truth, is come, he will guide you into all truth: for he shall not speak of himself; but whatsoever he shall hear, that shall he speak: and he will shew you things to come.”  The truth presented here is both a crystal-clear transparency and a version of reality that must seem alien to us creatures, accustomed as we are to the conceits of our senses and of our limited understandings combining to form our “realities.”

I see this emphasis on “truth” (though our version of it ought really to carry the quotation marks) as being entirely indispensable to our understandings of certain Gospel accounts.  An example is that of the Good Thief.  The standard notions of the story are forced and shaky, because there is no reason to accept that the Good Thief possessed any knowledge base commonly identified with “Jesus’ message,” and—most importantly—there is little if anything in the story that reflects the things that we are commonly supposed to do to get salvation.  “Remember me when you come into your kingdom” is of no more substance than the ill-fated utterances of others who will say to Jesus, “Lord, Lord” and “Did we not drive out demons in your name?”

The Good Thief, however, does do one thing of note.  The Good Thief reckons that Jesus has been true to his obligations, and is being unjustly punished.  The Good Thief reckons that Jesus is true and that the accusations against him are false.  The Good Thief reckons that Jesus will be true to his word when he promises to remember the Good Thief.

The Good Thief throws himself across the void of his suffering and into the arms of One whose character is utterly alien to himself.  I think there is much to be found in examination of our duty to embrace likewise a reality in Jesus that is utterly alien to the reality we possess.

Sunday, January 22, 2023

The Resolution of Things

In my last post I wrote:

“Creation is—in a manner existing before any subsequent specification—one thing.

“This is not idle musing.  It matters—most specifically it matters in terms of Jesus’ teaching—that all Creation is one Creation.  Such division that exists in Creation—to the extent that any division is real—exists in either a perfect, absolute sense through the will of God, or it exists in some provisional sense through the will of creatures.”

God made the universe.  God made Adam.  God made the universe and Adam was in that universe.  God made the universe and Adam was part of that universe.  All of these statements are true, and none of them are surprising.

However, it would be surprising to say that God made Adam and the universe was part of Adam—and yet the only thing that was of necessity “other” to Adam was God.  Adam’s random-seeming, impinging, uninvited passing thoughts might have seemed “other” to him.  Adam’s welling emotions might have seemed “other” to him.  Adam’s limbs and their capacity for space-filling, clumsiness, and discomfort might have seemed “other” to him.  Adam’s food and drink—and the sensations of ingesting them—might have seemed “other” to him.  The air that Adam breathed might have seemed “other” to him.  Adam’s physical surroundings (the physical surroundings by which his very bodily survival was made possible) might have seemed “other” to him.

This, again, is not idle musing.  God created Adam in a state of fellowship with God—although, in a manner reminiscent of the initial factual statement of Creation as created by God and yet pictured as pre-existing the narrative (“In the beginning . . .”), Adam’s state of fellowship with God is noted first in how it is past.  God’s first described observation of Adam (“It is not good that the man should be alone . . .”) reflects Adam’s shrinking from the pure Other.  Adam shows himself to be attuned not to a relationship that is yielding (his identity found in a melding with an Other that he trusts) but rather to a relationship (or set of relationships) that is referential.  That is, Adam will find his center of existence not in God, but in himself centered in an experience-realm where simultaneously he measures a distance from his surroundings so as to define himself, and also measures his surroundings by the proportions in which they reflect himself.

And so, God sets about addressing the less-than-optimal situation in which the man is “alone.”  The situation is an awkward one, and the reader of Genesis is not spared the awkwardness inherent in the impudent fashion in which the narrative smacks of approximation and adjustment on the part of God.  First, animals (drawn by God, it should be noted, from the substance of the earth, and not separately decreed into existence) are presented to Adam.  They will not suffice.  Then, the woman is drawn by God from the very substance of the man—as though the essential one-thing-ness of the universe is not a thing to be violated.

Adam’s apparent delight at the woman (“bone of my bones, and flesh of my flesh”) is the epitome of the quandary of “otherness” in human experience.  We desire that which is simultaneously like us and not like us.  Of course, the matter is not so simple.  Our initial dissatisfaction with God extends to every corner of our existence.  The man and the woman did not enjoy perfect communion, despite the denomination’s fixation on a fairy-tale simplicity of a Fall disrupting a perfect Paradise.  As must be admitted, even an abrupt Fall had to be presaged by unseemly thoughts on the part of our ancestors.  (And even a casual observer can note that the “curses” after the eating of the forbidden fruit were intensifications of already-existing travails characteristic of human life.)

It is not for nothing that Jesus returns again and again to “the beginning” or to the ancient roots of his listeners’ heritage, for Jesus is addressing those things that are most fundamental in life.  There is, however, no warrant to assume that Jesus’ references to the past are mere ratifications of what we consider the “natural order.”  Genesis, if approached with vigorous honesty, is revealed to be an account that is (by the very logic that necessitates the unfolding narrative) an account of a degraded state of existence becoming progressively more degraded.  What we consider to be “nature” is a set of conflicts and competitions between actors, and this continues to be so even if the matter is by degrees relieved by episodes of cooperation or conciliation.

Ultimately, what Jesus points us toward is not a resolution of conflicts, but rather an essential resolving of humanity’s original predicament—a broken communion with God, the Perfect Other.  As far as our relationship with Creation is concerned, for all the practical advice that Jesus gives us about how to get along with others, the sublime advices (nay, commands) that Jesus gives us about how to seek salvation are eminently impractical.  To be perfect, to be one with each other and with Jesus, to reckon ourselves to be possessors of all kingdoms while yet possessing nothing, to reckon the leveling of mountains at the mere thought to be as automatic as commanding our limbs, to see the exertions and trials of all ages and places as bound up in a simple, momentary act like handing out a cup of water—all of these things bespeak a notion of affinity with all Creation that makes sense only in light of a call to reach out to an awesome dis-affinity—communion with God, the Perfect Other.

Friday, January 20, 2023

The Puzzle of Things

I asserted in my previous post that nothing possesses of necessity any substance comparable to that of God.  By “comparable,” I am not referring to a matter of degree, such as might be inherent in asserting that God is “incomparable” to any lesser or inferior thing.  “Comparable” in this context means exactly that: “possessing characteristics amenable to comparison.”  God is not like anything else.

“Anything else,” then, falls by necessity into a certain category: those things that are not God.  “Those things that are not God” share a certain characteristic: they are all created—they all constitute Creation.  Creation, then, is distinguished first and foremost by a commonality.  Creation is—in a manner existing before any subsequent specification—one thing.

This is not idle musing.  It matters—most specifically it matters in terms of Jesus’ teaching—that all Creation is one Creation.  Such division that exists in Creation—to the extent that any division is real—exists in either a perfect, absolute sense through the will of God, or it exists in some provisional sense through the will of creatures.

The initial division between God and Creation is hidden from us in Genesis.  “Creation” in Genesis is described as a generic premise (“In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth”) or it is described as the provision of a counterbalance to an existing phenomenon (“Let there be light” presumes the existence of a created phenomenon of “darkness”) or it involves a schematic approximation of evolution (“Let the earth bring forth . . . .”)  “Creation” as an act, much though we might speak of it, is kept from us in the unspoken mysteries of the dark and hidden.  “The heaven and the earth” are not “created” for us in a retrospective display through the narrative.  Similarly, the conceptions of creatures are native to the inconceivable inner realms.  Even the “re-birth” of Jesus—so crucial to the logic of his ministry and so precious to the denominations’ presentations of their ministries—happens in the hidden realms and is described retrospectively, Genesis-like, in the Gospels (much to the frustration of the denominations.)

We are left, then, with a Creation that simply exists and that exists in its simplest form as one thing.  “Things”—entities that are described separately—are so described because God says they are separate or because creatures (let us confine “creatures” in this instance to “humans”) say they are separate.

Jesus provides an observation that dietary restrictions are untenable because what is taken in subsequently passes out.  If his contention here is taken at face value, one must conclude that Jesus would make a poor dietician.  Some of what is ingested becomes, of course, part of the body.  Some of it never leaves.  Jesus, however, maintains that the body is a thing, and also that the diet is an altogether separate thing,  There is a reason for Jesus’ logically untenable pronouncement about diet—he is describing impurity, and he maintains that true impurity is a pollution of the heart—of the inner person—and he is unconcerned here about how persons might pollute their innards.

We must contrast Jesus’ view here with Paul’s contention in First Corinthians that sexual immorality is particularly heinous in that it involves what a person does inside his or her body.  The “inside” part might lead to a little vagueness about what in particular is being done, but the matter scarcely deserves much analysis.  Paul’s contention is not merely specious in its assertion about the dishonoring of the body—clumsily described as part of Christ’s body, as though the imagery can well stand such simplicity.  Indeed, it is bad enough that Paul will describe the use of the body in, say, premarital sex, as especially egregious—as though employing one’s limbs in torturing an innocent or gesturing troops to perform a massacre would be a significantly less evil endeavor.

No, the most disturbing aspect of Paul’s “inside the body” take on sexual sin is that it flies in the face of Jesus’ painstaking assertions about what real evil is.  Real evil is describable not in terms of the physical nature, but rather in terms of the inclinations of the heart.  In purely logical terms, of course, Paul is the more literally accurate.  Paul is right to declare that sexual activity can affect the body, and Jesus is incorrect in asserting that what is ingested simply passes out “in the draught.”  Jesus, however, is ultimately correct—and divinely correct—on both scores.  Sexual sin is wrong most importantly in that it dishonors the bond—the one-thing-ness—of a person’s legitimate relationship, and other sins (let us consider here drunkenness, gluttony, substance abuse) are wrong most importantly in that they dishonor the bond--the one-thing-ness--of our relationships to Creation and to the Creator.

At bottom, then, is the importance of understanding that a fundamental presumption of the fact of our existences is our individual existence as part of a whole—however tenuous or extensively broken that whole might be.  We might be tempted to see the roiling, boiling turmoil of the initially-described Creation as a phenomenon of disunity.  Yet who are we to think so?  God at that narratively-described moment was in the company of the host of heaven, and surely the mere physical phenomena of the wave-tossed deep will never be plumbed by us, and must involve endless mysteries of grandeur beyond our ken.  God may have had in mind further developments of his Creation, but who are we to say that either God or Creation was then lacking?

In my next post I will try to show how the puzzle of “things” (though all things are part of one “thing”) has bedeviled the heritage of humanity, and also how understanding this puzzle is intrinsic to understanding the ministry of Jesus.

Following the Path of Expiation

It is unfortunately quite telling that much of Christianity cannot state with authority why Abel's sacrifice was looked upon with favor,...