Saturday, March 11, 2023

Social Dysfunction Goes Back to the Start

An example of reasoning based on a mistaken view of humanity’s original state, from:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/thechristianworldreview/2023/02/what-is-sin/

Nobody Understands Sin, by David Guill, February 26, 2023

“. . . Aquinas claimed that God created the world to function in a certain way and in accordance to certain principles. These principles are understood intuitively and can be further explored using our God-given ability to reason.

“A quick example could be our need for companionship. We are social creatures designed to live in large or small communities. From that starting point, we can logically conclude that murder and theft are wrong. After all, those actions inhibit our ability to live in social groups.”

This is incorrect.  Humanity was not designed as a collection of social creatures, or as individuals meant to be social creatures.  Humanity was meant to be in communion with God—the perfect Other—and in light of the incomprehensible otherness of God can be found no simple application of a “social”  relationship.

What was offered to Adam is difficult—perhaps impossible—for us to understand.  What we can understand, however, is the moral importance of reckoning our present status as “social creatures” to be problematic, not merely in our failed fulfillment of our obligations, but also in our latent tendencies to minimize our obligations overall.  To maintain, as Guill does, that we are “designed to live in large or small communities” is to give the game away, since the concepts of exclusion and alienation are implicit in the very concept of “community.”

From the “starting point” of our “need for companionship,” Guill says, “we can logically conclude that murder and theft are wrong.”  As though we humans did not routinely slaughter in our “tribal” (read: corollary of “community”) enterprises, and as though we humans did not routinely expropriate goods and services in innumerable schemes of ownership and privilege.  We call certain types of killing “murder,” because we are going to approve other types of killing.  We call certain types of appropriation “theft” because we are going to approve others—such approval, of course, being ratified for us by the communal structures in which we live.

If it is a matter of sorting out how to deal with our social entanglements (which God would have, apparently, spared Adam had Adam not displayed the need to not “be alone”), we must note that Jesus does not provide what we would conventionally call “help.”  Inflicting harsh behavior on a brother or sister would be called by Jesus “killing,” and Jesus solves any questions about ownership by requiring us to give everything away, either on our own initiative or at the request of those who would beg or borrow.  Good luck forging a communal order on those principles.

We were never meant, however, to live in communal order.  Adam was given Eve because he could not find community with the animals, and prior to that he was given the animals because he could not find community among the creations of Eden.  At this point—proceeding backward in the narrative—our access to explicit descriptions of Adam’s state fall away.  He was created by God.  No mortal can say why Adam would have not been created perfect, or would not have stayed perfect.  For us to wait until the “Fall” to pounce on some notion of “why” humanity is imperfect is just a craven game—as though the “rule” of a perfect God being expected to author perfect creations is at the “Fall” inexplicably lifted.

If there is any true application of the idea of humans as “social creatures,” then that application must be truly unyielding.  Our “society” as ordained by God must include all humans, and all creatures (offered, presumably, in good faith by God as suitable companions for us), and—in a progression of inescapable logic—all of the universe.  At this point of analysis, of course, we can realize that describing ourselves as rightly being “social creatures designed to live in large or small communities” has been rendered all but meaningless.

We were meant to be in society (for lack of a better word) with God.  We were never meant to forget that, and we were never meant to reckon that our moral requirements are any less than universal.

Thursday, March 9, 2023

The Wheel of Experience

I have been thinking lately about the concept of “paradox” in Jesus’ teachings.  Of course, there are few things commentators like better than to pronounce upon this or that as being some divinely-ordained “paradox.”  Often this seems to be linked to Paul writing about “foolishness,” or “weakness,” or some such.

It is, however, usually insipid to seize upon this or that aspect of Jesus’ ministry as being “paradoxical.”  Jesus’ ministry is delivered to us as we stand on the quintessential, foundational paradox—we are going to die (as we believe), yet we cannot for a moment conceptualize anything but the continuance of our experiences of life, and (ridiculous as this may sound) we actually have no reason for absolute assurance in the inevitability of our death.  Somebody of the ancient Greeks opined that death is the only cause for our indulgence of philosophy—if we did not face a self-acknowledged certainty of death (or of the possibility of death) we would not concern ourselves about such transcendent matters.

So we are convinced that we are going to die, and we prepare for it.  Or we come up with some philosophy (or cultivated predispositions of thought, though perhaps not deserving so refined a term as “philosophy”) that we use to avoid or forestall our contemplation of death.  In any event, the prospect of death constitutes the initial proposition of our metaphysical thought-lives—we “believe” in it.  Death is the first (or at least initially-appearing) god in our pantheon.  Even a child given a beginning in religion has not been given a lesson of substance unless he or she has been informed of the possibility of punishment (as close to the concept of death that the child can imagine) at the hands of the deity.  Until the notion of punishment has been introduced, any “god” that the young child hears about is no more than an invisible sky-uncle, believed in or not (or alternately believed in or not) at the merest whim.

We can be told stories or histories about a time before our individual selves, and we can understand that our experiences began around the time of our birth, but such understanding is not “true,”—it is believed to be true.  What is “true” is that we have never lived in an existence other than that which we remember—all else is conjectural.  All purportedly before that is conjectural.  What is “true” is that our experience of our experience-realm being continual and necessary for any existence we might have makes it impossible for us to consider a time when we might not exist.  We will always “live,” yet we resign ourselves to dying.  We “believe” in dying, in death.  Death is our first god.

The teachings of Jesus, of course, take as unquestioned the existence of a reality beyond the experiences of his listener.  Most crucially, however, the teachings of Jesus do not presuppose in the listener an ability to survey the full scope of time and existence.  There was a time before humanity, but that is not the same as to say that humanity exists on some segmented part of an understandable time-scale.  God created man in some certain way, and then the character of man was understood by God as unsuited to the original—as we believe—intent of God for untrammeled communion with man.  Man comes to be described in the narrative as needing other things.  “Man” as an element of the universe changes over time, culminating most notably in the experience of the first couple in the “Fall,” though it must be reckoned that the character of humanity is described as changing even further along in the Genesis narrative.

The upshot of all of this is the fact that our theology cannot plot events over a comprehensive time-scale.  Indeed, the idea of “time” as something that we can understand is as ludicrous as “death” as something we can understand.  We in our flailings-about to understand our existence rapidly and persistently deify both time and death.  In our attempts to understand (or to prime ourselves to be “awed by”) God—the God who exists always and everywhere—we make ourselves ridiculous in imagining we can understand time and space.

The foundational paradox of our relationship to the teachings of Jesus is the fact that the very premise of our attempts to understand is a premise of limited time and space.  Our lives pass on a scale that is foreign to our “understanding” of the timelessness of God, and our lives occur on a scale of dimensions that only in our conceit can we grasp as linear infinities.  Really our lives occur in the fleeting balls of balled-up experiences that each of us possesses.

Our relationship to God is experiential—yet we must acknowledge God as transcending all experience, and we must ask God to grant us experiences that must exist on planes that we cannot begin to imagine.  We are not asking for more and better, we are asking for we know not what.  Even a notion that we are asking for a state reminiscent of Adam’s original relationship with God is predicated—if Genesis as an origin-story is taken seriously—on our being granted a set of characteristics inherent in God’s original design for man—a design not described in the narrative of Genesis, which has the story of Adam begin narratively not with a perfect original state, but with the quandary of Adam needing other people.

So the whole idea of “paradox” in the teachings of Jesus is itself paradoxical.  Everything in the teachings of Jesus can be seen to cancel out some other element of the teachings of Jesus.  (How often do we hear, “But Jesus also said . . . .”)  Ultimately, however (“ultimately” being a paradoxical term here) the teachings of Jesus are meant to be applied to our experiences—and in the realm of our experiences—and our experience-states change.  Our experiences cancel each other out.  In the rushing, overlapping cycles of “rousing, readying, and reaping,” we are dipped as though on a wheel into experience-states for which in their particulars Jesus’ teachings are suited.

Sunday, March 5, 2023

Hunter Gatherers of Men

In the Bible’s account of the murder of Abel, a man—to whom was ascribed no wrongdoing—was killed by his brother.  In the New Testament account of the murder of John the Baptist, the victim was attainted with no wrongdoing—and he was killed by a man (“Herod the tetrarch”) who purported to adhere to the same moral code as John.

In each instance, the chief detectable source (one might say “well-spring”) of the animosity of the murderer toward his victim was the fact that the victim’s very comportment served as a reminder of the latent murderer’s failings.  Abel did Cain no wrong, and John did Herod no wrong.  Indeed, Abel and John were merely doing their duties.

It would be presumptuous, however, to claim that Abel or John exhibited extraordinary virtues.  Indeed, there is no cause to assume that those murdered unfortunates could say anything other than (as Jesus might phrase it), “We are but miserable servants.  We have only done our duty.”  Abel and John are hailed as prophets, but it is their highlighting of wrongdoing (no small matter, to be sure) that distinguishes them.

The function of those prophets was to make plain the demands of God.  John’s career, especially, shows the “proclaiming” aspect of the prophets in high relief.  Famously, the Old Testament ends with the promise from the Book of Malachi:

“Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the Lord.”

Equally famously, the gospels wrestle with the notion of the fulfillment of this prophecy in John the Baptist, who answered thus about himself:

“And they asked him, What then?  Art thou Elias?  And he saith, I am not.”

Yet Jesus says of John:

“For all the prophets and the law prophesied until John, And if ye will receive it, this is Elias, which was for to come.  He that hath ears to hear, let him hear.”

The whole notion of the return of Elijah—even of the function of the prophets themselves—is bound up with the experiential aspect of the urgency of God’s commands.  “Experiential” is the key—nothing, for example, about the career of John hinges on whether or not he saw himself as a prophet.  The “prophetic message” is a thing unto itself, not an aspect of a “job description” of a “prophet.”

There is more, however, in the commonalities between Abel and John the Baptist that illustrate the undertakings (and hardships and demands) of the prophetic function.  First, and perhaps most importantly, is the experiential effect of prophecy in a sense of urgency.  Cain, while his sacrifice has not been accepted, is not told by God that he is damned.  God tells Cain that sin is crouched in waiting for him.  John tells the wicked of the Jews that holy wrath awaits them—and that nothing in their status as Abraham’s offspring will avail them in the judgment.  Only the urgency of repentance will save them.

A sense of urgency, however, does not comport well with a sense of being settled.  When Jesus sends the disciples out on their missions, he does not send them out to found churches (or proto-churches) or to appoint local leaders in the towns and villages.  Jesus sends the disciples out to course through the territories as catalysts of experience.  His description of their journey proceeds from the mundane to the apocalyptic.  One moment Jesus is talking about tunics and staffs, the next moment about persecution, the next moment about the impossibility of the disciples completing their mission, the next moment about the end of the age.

All of this folds back into the common human experiences of exhilarating or terrifying change versus the comfort and assurance of settlement.  Abel and John are not settling characters.  Abel especially is enigmatic.  Something about that man and his sacrifice was pleasing to God.  (And let us not entertain any unsubstantiated notions such as certain artists’ desire to portray Abel as a youth set upon by a full-grown elder brother.)  What about Abel’s offering distinguished it from Cain’s?  The commentators have been forced, after all, to note that the Law considered a bloodless sacrifice to be acceptable.  Surely Abel’s role as an animal-slaughterer was not what set him above his brother.

Of course, Abel’s role as an animal-slaughterer is puzzling in itself.  Unless Abel thought up the grisly business of eating his flock—and translated that concept to the God before whom he lay their carcasses and “the fat thereof”, with divine permission to eat animals still in the post-Flood future—it must be thought that God had instructed Abel in his offering, a detail hidden from us.  The commentators have exerted themselves to find some cause by which Abel’s offering was preferred to Cain’s (as though the two brothers might not have both earned sufficient—though differing—“passing grades.”  They were not, after all, in competition with each other.)

Much has been made of Abel offering “of the firstlings of the flock,” but the salient aspect of a sacrifice’s suitability (according to “the Law”) was that it be “without blemish”—an aspect that the Genesis account omits.  Are we to know that Cain’s second-day harvesting of “the fruit of the ground” did not contain the most perfect specimens?  Or that the initial season’s harvest of “the fruit of the ground” was not its “firstlings”?

Really, we have before us in the examples of Abel and John the Baptist two men dressed in the skins of animals (assuming, as seems reasonable, that Abel was attired similarly to his parents.  Here, at least, we might have cause to imagine Abel wearing something that did not die by itself, though we are still left with "the fat thereof” being mere refuse to a vegetarian Abel—scarcely the stuff of sacrifice.)  That is to say, we have Abel and John the Baptist dressed in the skins of mammals while eschewing a diet more sentient than locusts.

What we have before us is two men who have distanced themselves from the more enticing aspects of settled civilization.  I realize that I have worked myself around to one of the favorite themes of secular analysts about the Cain and Abel story—that it is the primordial memory of an ages-long struggle between pastoralists and planters.  What is not usually linked to this school of conjecture is any concerted analysis to the effect that, for the Bible, there is really nothing “primordial” about it.  The pastoralist is not contrasted merely with the planter, but also with the urban civilizations dependent on plant-agriculture.  Indeed, the Bible begins and ends with cities viewed as sinkholes of depravity—a theme that is blunted in its development by the emphasis—for good or ill—on the persistent notions of a righteous “City of David” or some vision of Jerusalem, or on the unsurprising choice of cities as the loci of primitive churches.

Yet we must remember that evil cities (Sodom and Gomorrah, Babylon, even the hapless towns of Chorazin, Bethsaida, and Capernaum) are not just “bad apples” in the bin of urbanization.  The gathering of peoples is not the good, in the teachings of Jesus or in the scriptures to which he subscribes, that it is often imagined to be.  The tower of Babel is just the prime example.  Humanity was commanded to multiply and fill the earth, and yet people—so the account relates—wanted to make a great city and also to make a name for themselves.  The “name” part is particularly puzzling—either they saw themselves as inhabiting an earth also “peopled” by other non-human beings, or the “name” is simply a majoritarian voice of a segment of humanity wishing to secure for themselves the benefits of urbanization in distinction to fewer and lesser outlying peoples.  Neither notion, of course, would be deemed acceptable by the narrative.

Nothing about the singularity of the tower of Babel in the narrative precludes the notion that “Babel-ism” in itself defies God’s original decree.  Would one great city on each continent mean that humanity had multiplied and filled the earth?  Would a sprinkling of smaller “great cities” equal a “filling of the earth?”  And would any of this diminishment of size relate necessarily to the desire to—Babel-like—raise humanity with presumption in the face of God?  (“And thou, Capernaum, which are exalted unto heaven, shalt be brought down to hell.”)

And so, as I wrote above, we have Abel and John the Baptist dressed in the skins of mammals while eschewing a diet more sentient than locusts.  What is more, we have a logic of “mission” and of “prophetic ministry” in the teachings of Jesus that—in the all-important experiential sense—drives logically and inescapably toward the “sowing” of Jesus’ followers into the fields of the earth, rather than the “gathering” of his followers into churches.  The fact that Jesus will be present when “two or three” are gathered together in his name is a fact that draws its force from the underlying experiential premise of Jesus’ teachings.  For human beings to meet and interact fruitfully is always a rare occurrence—rare, that is, in comparison to the perpetual din of forced fellowship and of self-reinforcing convenience in thought and manners.

In the episode of Cain and Abel, the blood of the murdered brother might have cried out for vengeance, but the interaction of God and the murderer is not without hope.  God had warned Cain that evil is crouching for him, and God couched that warning—and the corollary of hope—in language that tells Cain that so much as the settled atmosphere of his tent-flap or doorway is a danger to him.  Even the “curse” of the ground refusing to submit to Cain’s tillage could be a blessing to him, as the deprivations of a wilderness life might bring him to repentance.  And Cain’s response?  To take God’s guarantee of personal protection with him as he goes off to build a city.  Inasmuch as the surrounding fields will refuse to grow for Cain personally, well, it does not take much to imagine the development of forced labor and of social stratification.

And then there is John the Baptist, immersing the repentant in the Jordan and sending them on their way.  Or dousing the hypocritical in scorn and sending them on their way.  Or splintering off disciples for Jesus.   And then there is Jesus, splintering and shattering society in virtually every way imaginable.

Family is nothing, until—when the prophetic Elijah-moment arises—it is everything.  Jesus’ mother dwells in the shadows of his life until he must draw her out of the shadows and place her in another’s care.

Friendship is nothing until—when the prophetic Elijah-moment arises—it is everything.  The disciples are sent off to minister to strangers and told not to even salute people on the road.  Then they are told that they must be ever ready to sacrifice their lives for their friends.

Marriage is nothing until—when the prophetic Elijah-moment arises—it is everything.  A spouse is (as is every other person) a source of attachment to the follower of Jesus that threatens ever to blunt the follower’s mission and concentration—until the question becomes the existential one of choosing life individually versus the welfare of the spouse.

Religion is nothing until—when the prophetic Elijah-moment arises—it is everything.  Religious obligation is indistinguishable from social or legal obligations (no matter how tenuous or obscure the relationships of obligation between those realms), until some overriding crisis.  One moment religious obligation is—to cite the example of Jesus’ time and locality—a question of obeying those who occupy Moses’ seat, and the next moment religious obligation is remembering that the earth is God’s footstool.

From the beginning of—and throughout—the story of the world told by Jesus, the emphasis has been on the scattering of his ministry by followers of his willing to trust themselves to the wind (to use Jesus’ John 3 metaphor) of what appears to us to be inscrutable fortune.  All of this is in distinction to the notions of the denominations, which by definition emphasize centrality of thought and the subsuming of real experience to whipped-up ideas about what religion should feel like.  The denominations must distinguish themselves by doctrine, which makes no sense unless what is thought proper to think and feel is contrasted to what is thought improper to think and feel.

In conventional Christianity, the field of mission is a field of hard ground that must be either tilled with hard implements or subjected in its fruits to hard examination—two notions that would not be pernicious in themselves, except that they are founded on the all-too-easy premise that following Jesus can be described in such definite sense as to be accessible and understandable independently of the momentary content of one’s experience-realm.  It cannot.  The guests cannot mourn while the bridegroom is present, the faithful cannot keep the Sabbath at the cost of others’ suffering, and the Messiah that must be David’s son cannot be David’s son—or can he?

Ultimately, the followers of Jesus—and the collective following of Jesus—cannot be afraid of splintering apart.  Denominations must emphasize centrality, and so the logic of going into the world must assume that few will respond to Jesus’ call.  Jesus, on the other hand, describes a harvest greater than may be gathered—what is lacking is workers willing to learn what they are teaching even as they are teaching it.

Jesus’ metaphor of the worker in the field is not the one who plants, but the one who gleans—the one who knows not where he or she comes from or is going.  God is the one who plants.  Jesus gave the first disciples a challenge indeed when he took them from their nets and made them “fishers of men.”  Translated to the land, Jesus made them—in shades of Abel and John—“hunter-gatherers of men.”

Wednesday, February 22, 2023

That Wretched Real Man

Each of the Synoptic Gospels describes early on the wilderness temptation of Jesus by the devil.  Mark’s perfunctory description is unproblematic, but Matthew and Luke describe three temptation events individually and disagree on the order.  A standard explanation of the disagreement seems to be presented in the book Hard Sayings of the Bible (Walter C. Kaiser, Jr., et al., 1996 edition used):

“Each orders the testings of Jesus and mentions details to bring out their picture.  Both pictures are true, but neither is complete in itself.  If we lacked either picture we would be poorer.  This is why it is important to read each Gospel for itself and to get the distinctive message each author is proclaiming, to see the picture each author is painting.  If we try to merge them together to get a homogenized harmony we lose these distinctive contributions, moving from books Christians believe God inspired to an interest in mere history.”

Of course, it can be amusing to note the authors’ contention that working out a “homogenized harmony” of accounts of the Savior’s universe-shaking lone battle with the Tempter would betray “an interest in mere history.”  What is more important to note in rationalizations such as that above (and others like it) is the way the authors grant themselves the edge in every nuance.  They write of the differing accounts of the temptations in Matthew and Luke, “Both pictures are true, but neither is complete in itself.”  Of course, they are complete in themselves—that is why commentators (like those above) must contend that the Gospel accounts differ because of the themes the Gospel writers want to bring out in their respective stories.  Writing a gospel that conflicts with another on a statement of fact does not “complete” the other, nor does it lend to the two conflicting gospels being more “complete” together—all that is “complete’’ in such an instance is the body of Scripture that the commentator has to work with (with all its attendant difficulties.)

Of course, the “conflict” (such as between Matthew and Luke on the temptations) must be shown to be direct—a gospel that leaves out (or appears to leave out) a detail presented in another gospel does not conflict necessarily with the latter.  A prime example of this is the gospels’ descriptions of the two condemned with Jesus—John and Mark describe their presence matter-of-factly (though some manuscripts of Mark include an Old Testament allusion), while Luke includes most notably the Good Thief upbraiding his fellow for the latter’s insults of Jesus, and in Luke the Good Thief receives the hopeful promise of salvation from Jesus.

Then there is Matthew, which has both insulting Jesus (at first?):

“Likewise also the chief priests mocking him, with the scribes and elders, said, He saved others; himself he cannot save.  If he be the King of Israel, let him now come down from the cross, and we will believe him.  He trusted in God; let him deliver him now, if he will have him: for he said, I am the Son of God.  The thieves also, which were crucified with him, cast the same in his teeth.”

Of course, if the Bible were held to be (as, unfortunately, it is held often to be) a seamless and unproblematic book of books, then the literary lurch between the Matthew thief (casting “the same” in Jesus’ “teeth”) and the Luke thief (“remember me when thou comest into thy kingdom”) would be neither more nor less than an embarrassment.  One can contend that one of the “thieves” changed his mind.

It is at this point that I must emphasize this blog’s focus on moments.  Moments are experienced, and each episode of attention-commanding experience is a moment.  And to each moment we are roused, readied, and reaped.

And if we are to understand Jesus’ teachings, we must understand Jesus’ emphasis on moments.  In the teachings of Jesus time and place are rendered infinitely malleable.  It is ridiculous to try to work out details of time and place in contemplating Jesus’ teachings, since his abiding and all-encompassing command is to submerge such particulars (which otherwise we collect and frame as our “lives”) into the experiential realm of the kingdom of God.

It is in terms of experiences that we must view the accounts of the gospels and of the scriptures to which Jesus draws our attention.  Most critical of all this is our understanding of (or attempts to understand) the experiences of Jesus.  “The experiences of Jesus” is one of the most problematic aspects of organized Christianity, since the topic of Jesus’ experiences is one of the religious topics subjected most fiercely to ideological abuse.  One wonders if Jesus’ physical and psychological abuse in the course of the Crucifixion is dwarfed by the horrific presumptions upon his experiences committed by theologians.  One would think that Jesus’ sacrificial torments would be reckoned the great theological holy ground untrammeled by divines, yet in their frantic need to extract supportable “salvation economies” upon which to base their denominations, theologians expound endlessly upon the height and depth and breadth and duration of Jesus’ agonies.

A person can spend a pious lifetime expounding on how the sins of all mankind were piling on top of the cross that Jesus bore.  Then again, there was the contribution of Simon of Cyrene.  A person can attempt to formulate an equation by which Jesus suffered the equivalent of eternities of suffering of all mankind (or, if you prefer, of all of the elect), although infinities and eternities do not fit well into our equations.  And then again, there is the surprise on the part of experienced agony-producers at how short a time Jesus lasted on the Cross (though the onset of the festival was going to cut short the agonies of Jesus and his condemned fellows at any rate.)  This type of conjecture is not merely ridiculous, but ultimately impious.

We cannot even begin to conjecture on the sufferings of Jesus.  When we try to do so, we do so in ways that betray our self-centered emphases.  When we want to construct a salvation economy, no pains will be spared in conjecturing about the aspects of Jesus’ suffering.  When we want to construct an argument for our version of Scripture, we will contort ourselves appallingly rather than abide the notion of a disjointed and cumbersome body of literature about Jesus.  The business of manipulating the extant scriptures is especially problematic in how this business discounts the experiential aspect of Jesus’ ministry.  We see this phenomenon in both of the examples (different in other respects) described above—the Order of the Temptations and the Behavior of the Crucified Criminals.

Arguments about the Temptations as presented in the gospels rely generally on considering certain related aspects of the narratives as being understandable in terms of writers’ viewpoints.  This or that order of the temptations related by this or that Greek phraseology representing this or that Hebrew (or Aramaic) utterance between Jesus and Satan are batted around endlessly.  Did Jesus and Satan even speak a post-Babel language to each other?  (Can we ever stop revisiting the notion that Hebrew was the “original language,” based on sophomoric word-play in Genesis?)  Did Jesus and Satan speak any language at all to each other?  Were the temptations limited to those described in the texts?  The (presumably and apparently) original description in Mark sure sounds like forty days of torment.  Who are we to imagine otherwise?  When the emphasis on the Temptations is “scriptural” rather than “experiential,” the Temptations come across as little more than high-school debating exercises.  Indeed, high school students would seem to suffer more exasperating temptations.

Jesus’ punishments were beyond imagining.  Jesus’ temptations were beyond imagining.  Either these things are true, or Jesus’ stature as the Son of God does not mean what we claim it means.  Only our experiential participation in the life that Jesus offers to us can direct us toward any understanding, and that very “directing” is intrinsically related to an understanding that we can never comprehend the divine.

We cannot forget the other example presented above, the Behavior of the Crucified Criminals.  The reason it does not matter whether they both derided Jesus until he died, or whether one of them repented and sought Jesus’ favor, is because Jesus knew the full experience of both scenarios—just as he knew the full life-story of everyone in the crowd ridiculing him.  Just as he knew the exhaustive details not merely of the lives of all the onlookers, but of how their lives—and presumably their attitudes toward him—would have or could have been affected by any experience they had faced, or would face.

There is an even more pointed example of how we will do well to focus on experiential aspects of Jesus’ ministry, rather than upon trying to construct a narrative.  This example is Jesus’ betrayal by Judas.  Judas has been raised in our communal lore as the most despicable of evil-doers, and little else might be expected of a “scriptural” heritage that considers him greedy, self-righteous, hypocritical, cowardly, and impious—to say nothing of devil-possessed.  It is this last point, however (devil-possession) that can help us throw Judas into proper light.

The Judas of John was a thief who became possessed by the devil.  The great crime of this Judas was thievery—unless we consider ourselves qualified to opine on devil-possession (and are prepared to deliver the pronouncement that Judas, and not Satan, bore the guilt of it.)

The Judas of Luke was simply devil-possessed and went to arrange (apparently) for money in return for the betrayal—the money presumably being more important to this Judas than to the devil who possessed him.

And, of course, since it seems that Jesus considered Peter little better than Satan if Peter were to hinder Jesus from his fate, it seems indeed strange than Satan would positively thrust Jesus toward that same fate.  Such, to say the least, is the sort of conundrum we enter when we start puzzling out demon-possession.  We have no more grounds to say that we can understand the devil-possessed Judas of John or of Luke than to say that we can understand the fallen angels.  It is beyond us.

Then there is the Judas of Mark, who does not even seem to have predicated his betrayal on monetary payment (or at least the translators seem unable to work the language that way.)  The Judas of Mark hands Jesus over to the authorities and bids them to keep Jesus well-guarded (or is it safely guarded?)  The Judas of Mark did what he did because the Judas of Mark did what he did.  The rest is beyond us.

And then finally there is the Judas of Matthew.  The book of Matthew is filled with alternating criticisms by Jesus of the people, and then of their leadership, and then of the people, and then of their leadership, and so on.  This is the gospel in which Jesus tells the people that they are to do what the scribes and Pharisees tell them to do.  This is the gospel in which Jesus says of the Pharisees “leave them,” or “let them alone.”  It would not be rash to assume that Jesus would get into trouble with the law, but for what, and with what gravity?

And so Judas goes to the authorities (whose internal deliberations would be hidden from him) and asks, “What will ye give me, and I will deliver him unto you?”  They offer him thirty pieces of silver—enough to pay the temple tax for sixty men.  He is expected to betray Jesus, who likes to tells parables about millions of dollars in gold—for enough to pay the temple tax for sixty men.  Judas is expected—the Judas who the expositors like to imagine in league with immensely powerful men scheming to hold power under the mighty Roman Empire—this same Judas is expected to expose himself in something like a scene of darkness and torches and swords and potential panic, for enough to pay the temple tax for sixty men?

Judas, who has no reason to assume that Jesus will get more than the flogging that Pilate offers (and the type of punishment that the Apostles discover will be handed out by Levantine leaders almost as an afterthought) asks, “What will ye give me, and I will deliver him unto you?”  The pittance he is promised might easily be translated by him into a statement—perhaps an assurance—that Jesus would be punished with a misdemeanor, and hopefully dissuaded in future.  We can think worse of Judas if we like, but he is at least a human being, and (unlike the demonic Judases of Luke and John and the sketch figure of Mark) the Judas of Matthew is a human being who we can try to understand.

And so Matthew continues:

“Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that he was condemned, repented himself, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and elders, Saying, I have sinned in that I have betrayed the innocent blood.”

What foul contagion of the most brutish ages of history would prompt two thousand years of Christianity to throw their eyes over this verse of Judas’ anguish and assign to him the role of devil incarnate?  The reduction of Judas to a soulless caricature would be bad enough, but there is a still greater evil here.  Judas’ prospective Savior has since the world’s beginning shouldered every burden and felt every pain of Creation—no follower of Jesus could possibly imagine otherwise.  And no follower of Jesus, in good conscience and confronted by the matter, would ever exempt from consideration any cause to contemplate a source of Jesus’ pain.

The only analyzable story of Judas in the gospels is found in Matthew.  It is a story of a man aghast at what he has gotten himself into, and what he has joined others in doing.  It must have been agony to him, and the suffering of Judas must have been agony to Jesus.  There is really no mystery here, no “How could anyone have shared earthly fellowship with Jesus and then have turned away?”  They all turned away—Judas, the fleeing disciples, the crowds, “all the people.”  And they all have been joined by the rest of us throughout history—our history—when too often we have recalled with remorse what we have gotten ourselves into, and what we have joined others in doing.

There is only one abiding lesson of the Temptations, the accounts of which are bound to be jumbled in the transmitting and the translation: Jesus was there, and he felt it.  There is only one abiding lesson of the thieves on Jesus’ left and right, whose agonies were mingled for Jesus with his own: Jesus was there, and he felt it.  There is only one abiding lesson of Judas’ act of betrayal, which involved real, not cartoonish, behaviors on the part of that wretched real man: Jesus was there, and he felt it.

Monday, February 13, 2023

Surrender in the Moment

It is time for me to focus more closely on the implications of “roused, readied, reaped.”  The concept of “roused, readied, reaped,” as I have tried to describe it, is meant to relate a phenomenon that—in its nearly infinite manifestations—characterizes human experience.  The cycles of rousing, readying, and reaping occur in every plane, through all times, and in varying duration throughout our mortal lives.  Even the very concept of “the moment” (or “the instant”, if you prefer) entails in our conceptualization the tiniest of experienceable time-frames.  A moment is a span in which something happens (or notably does not happen)—no matter how tiny or fleeting a moment is, it exists as a span of time.

So, there is no such thing as the “instantaneous,” if by that we mean something that occurs in “no time” and could be experienced by us as such.  Yet, of course, the briefest of moments are usually the most difficult for us to manage (or, most importantly, for us to manage ourselves within.)  In the moments of our lives, we are thrown up against our most undiluted dispositions and are deprived largely (if we address those moments in concerted fashion) of recourse to mental constructions of the surrounding time and place.

So, in the moments of our lives, we are (if we are willing to accept it) deprived of the constructions of time and place that constitute our inwardly-appreciated lives.  A moment truly lived is a moment outside of the lives we know, and it is in the Jesus-approved focus on moments that we find the greater life that he promises us.  Or, to put it another way (and this is the key, I believe, to understanding the ministry of Jesus), we find the greater life that Jesus promises us when we cease to see ourselves as possessing lives in which Jesus intercedes periodically, and when we begin to see that the life of Jesus is all that really exists, and our own “lives” are those self-bounded realms of referential assurances that are really self-reflections.  We are not wakened to supernatural events that we might associate either with miraculous revelation or with life-changing moral challenges—we are wakened to the Jesus-mediated life that really exists, and in those moments we are lifted out of the un-miraculous mire of that which we each in our own way label “real life.”

This is how the story of Jesus begins in the Gospel of John.  Here I must apologize for using the phrase “story of Jesus,” yet it is not without reason that I use it.  The gospels, or stories drawn from an amalgamation of the gospels, can be called “Lives of Christ,” and it is usually with the greatest of reverence that they are so called.  Unfortunately, the notion of a “life of Christ” is terribly misleading, and this fact can be demonstrated best by the beginning of John.  Here we can begin to see that, as I stated above, “the life of Jesus is all that really exists, and our own ‘lives’ are those self-bounded realms of referential assurances that are really self-reflections.”

In fact, the first part of John can be called most revealingly the “life of humanity,” with Jesus’ character the sole static element—only Jesus’ fleshly manifestation participates in the story with us, and the recurring effect of the story is to show how we are raised up (or hauled up) in moments long or short into the glare of God’s truth.

“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.  The same was in the beginning with God.  All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made.”

We can call this part of a narrative, yet it is as much part of a narrative as “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth”—it is a pre-story, started and finished as a premise, not as a Chapter One of the story.  So far there has been described no process conceivable to us.

“In him was life; and the life was the light of men.  And the light shineth in darkness; and the darkness comprehended it not.”

It is inconceivable that the light that “shineth in darkness” did not precede the creation of humanity, and if this “light” is the “life” in Jesus (“the Word”), then there is no way that we might conceive of it as other than pre-existing the creation even of physical darkness.  Again, we are being given premises, not elements of narrative.

“There was a man sent from God, whose name was John.  The same came for a witness, to bear witness of the Light, that all men through him might believe.  He was not that Light, but was sent to bear witness of that Light.”

John participates in the story, but he does so as a person thrust into the narrative (or, if you will permit, “roused” to his calling.)  In every moment in which he responded to his calling (and it does not seem later that his focus is all that God might have intended it to be), John was living the true life offered to him (and to all.)  John is describe as interacting, not with a narrative Jesus, but with a stable and endless stream of the changeless character of Jesus.

“That was the true Light, which lighteth every man that cometh into the world.  He was in the world, and the world was made by him, and the world knew him not.”

Again, the point is made—Jesus as an element of the salvation-story of his ministry is as an overarching, impending (some might say intrusive) source of light.  He exists in the story as an agent from time immemorial until time unimaginable.   The KJV has as above, “That was the true Light, which lighteth every man that cometh into the world” (1:9).  The New Jerusalem Bible has the verse as, “The Word was the real light that gives light to everyone; he was coming into the world”—but for our purposes the import is the same.  Jesus in the gospels is described as something happening, but it is never forgotten that Jesus is always and everywhere something happening.

The “story” of the Gospels is the story of how persons are shaped by moments of dealing with Jesus, but the very fact of the ubiquitous and changeless nature of Jesus’ interactions with Creation makes plain a simple fact.  People are not changed because Jesus or an agent of Jesus breaks into their lives.  People are changed because their lives are broken (even if not totally or forever) as those people are lifted into the life of Jesus.  People are given chances (monumental or mundane, brief or long) that are the “rousings”, “readyings,” and “reapings” of mere existence.  The light of Jesus always shines (or scorches) and in moments of recognition of that light we are blinded to all surroundings and unconscious of time.  Our lives are shorn from us, and we are well rid of them, and we have to assent simultaneously to letting them go.

How this is to be done (or at least addressed) is exemplified by the quote from the Baptist later in the introduction to the Gospel:

“John bare witness of him, and cried, saying, This was he of whom I spake, He that cometh after me is preferred before me: for he was before me.”

John the Baptist interacted with the fleshly Jesus, but (as the verse just above makes plain) John was capable of understanding that the character of the divine Jesus exudes divine light always.  As I wrote above, when properly oriented to Jesus, “John is describe as interacting, not with a narrative Jesus, but with a stable and endless stream of the changeless character of Jesus.”  It is only when John looks at Jesus as a time- or place-dependent person that John ceases to have a proper understanding of Jesus, as in when he sends his disciples to ask if Jesus is the one for whom he had been waiting.

How different is this confused and worldly John from his very self a few years earlier, when he had said of Jesus, “he will thoroughly purge his floor, and will gather the wheat into his garner; but the chaff he will burn with fire unquenchable”!  The Baptist’s experience, however, is not fundamentally different from anyone else’s—we have moments that overtake our lives, that become our lives, but of course we do not handle those moments perfectly, and they do not last.

Faced, however, with the impermanence of our moments of enlightenment, we tend unfortunately to decide that such fervor is rare (and probably just as well rare) and needs to be supplanted gradually by a more mature faith that by bits and pieces stores away a more sober and ostensibly more certain approach to Jesus’ teachings.  And then we sift through our stores of “faith” and content ourselves that we are learning to be ready to answer the calls of challenge that Jesus might thrust into our lives.  And then we think of time and place and of how blessed we are to have a sure theology and to partake of what we term the “abundant life” of believers enjoying the blessings of God’s creation.

And then we are wakened from our slumber by the voice that says, “You fool!  This very night your life will be required of you!”

What will time and place, what will our very lives themselves, mean to us then?  How might we ever answer, not merely for what we have done, but for what we have left undone?  I have no better answer than anyone for my own life, but here I want to highlight in any event the very pitfalls of an internalized “life” itself.  The only life to which we must aspire is that which finds its substance in the character of Jesus, and therefore by definition finds no substance in itself.  And the only source of instruction on this matter in the teachings of Jesus is to be found in the most unsparing assessment of his ministry itself.

Jesus went often by himself to pray.  Jesus went often to tend to the needy.  We also do such things (though neither kind of thing intently enough.)  Of course we tend to make assumptions about our moral character that will allow a far greater (in fact, infinitely greater) degree of failing on our part than on the part of Jesus.  When we pray, our minds wander.  When we attempt to address the needs of the needy, we stint.  Of course, we will say, our actions in such regards will always be lacking, and we might even indulge in examinations of ourselves in light of some theory of “total depravity.”  Fair enough.

But what shields the behavior of Jesus from such unsparing analysis, save our determination to account him unassailable by any observation?  Skeptics enough will tell us that Jesus lied about attending the festival, that he acted spitefully in cursing the fig tree, that he prescribed unstinting adherence to the Law while defying many of its provisions, that he treated his parents deplorably.

The answer to such contentions, I will argue (in accordance with the moment-by-moment implications of “roused, readied, reaped”) is found in the general scheme of analysis inherent in the introduction to John.  The vindication of Jesus (and the only hope for us to claim shelter in his eternal and ubiquitous mercy) is found in the moment-by-moment grasping at the eternal and ubiquitous nature of Jesus.  Sure, we can haul out schemes of moral analysis, but any merciless application of such a scheme (either by skeptic or by “total depravity” adherent) can claim victory on its own terms.  If merciless analysis is to be applied, why would we not look at Jesus in his very agony in the Garden?  If it were as simple a matter as Jesus being sinless (and as simple a matter as Jesus being analyzed like any human), might we not attribute sin to him even in his very agonies?  If he were sinless, would he not accept his fate serenely, and pursue the positive moral good of comforting his disciples?  It would be harsh enough for us ask such questions, but if we were honest with ourselves, we would admit that placed in such danger as Jesus contemplated, any higher thoughts we might have would be tinged (at least) by baser thoughts.

Or is Jesus’ sinless acceptance of his fate really what the Agony in the Garden all about?  Jesus, quite apparently, does not “accept” his fate except as a latent possibility through the long years of his life and the harrowing years of his ministry.  He asks to be spared his fate.  He accepts it in the moment.  IN THE MOMENT.  In the moment, his life is nothing but submission to God’s will.  He promises us nothing more, and it might be said that he “promises” us a good portion of suffering—all so that we might sacrifice all that we call our “lives,” and all for the sake of a “life” that finds its purpose in anything but ourselves.

We cannot do what Jesus asks except moment by moment.  The gospel accounts of his ministry have tortured us (and led to innumerable tortured commentaries) by how they return again and again to requirements of us that fall apart when “sinlessness” is held to be the issue, and that make no sense unless surrender in the moment is the issue.

Following the Path of Expiation

It is unfortunately quite telling that much of Christianity cannot state with authority why Abel's sacrifice was looked upon with favor,...